Tag

KF #21. Builds Networks

1195: How to Beat AI Applications and Win Your Job Hunt with Steve Dalton

By Podcasts No Comments

Steve Dalton reveals the most efficient way to secure advocates and open the path to your dream career.

You’ll Learn

  1. The critical job hunting skill most don’t learn
  2. How AI is making the job search worse—and how it can still help you
  3. The 7-point email that turns strangers into advocates

About Steve

Steve Dalton is the author of The 2-Hour Job Search and The Job Closer, which have sold more than 100,000 copies worldwide, been taught at over 150 universities, and adapted for use by Fortune 500 companies. His work is known for turning networking and relationship building into clear, repeatable systems for people who don’t consider themselves natural networkers. 

Dalton developed his approach during the 2008 financial crisis after seeing talented job seekers overwhelmed by advice that worked only for a lucky few. He has since delivered hundreds of workshops and keynotes for universities, employers, and professional organizations. Earlier in his career, he worked as a chemical engineer, strategy consultant, and marketer. Dalton holds an MBA from Duke University.

Resources Mentioned

Thank you, Sponsors!

  • Vinted. Download the Vinted app for free to start selling with no seller fees!
  • Mint Mobile. Get your wireless plan for $15/month!

Pete Mockaitis
Steve, welcome back!

Steve Dalton

Great to be back.

Pete Mockaitis
Well, I am so excited to chat with you again to talk about the third edition of The 2-Hour Job Search and more. You know, Steve, I have mentioned to you, and I think I’m going to share this with the listeners as well, that I think of you every time I clean my toilet. No joke. Have you heard that before?

Steve Dalton
I have heard that before, actually.

Pete Mockaitis
Yeah. Well, it’s kind of special, and I hope you don’t mind.

Steve Dalton
I consider it a position of honor, frankly. My favorite chore, or, at least, unfavorite chore.

Pete Mockaitis

Indeed. And so that was in our previous conversation, which I 100% recommend every person hear, especially if you’re looking for a job or you know someone dear who’s looking for a job.

You are my go-to that I send people to, and I’ve had other listeners say the same. But just for those wondering, toilets, explain, Steve. Toilets?

Steve Dalton
There’s a special thing about the word favorite because it allows you to talk about unsavory experiences in a positive way. The way I describe this is I’m going to give you three statements, only one of which is true. “I really enjoy cleaning the toilet” is the first. The second, “I’m very passionate about cleaning the toilet.” And the third, “My favorite chore is cleaning the toilet.”

For the logicians out there, you might be able to figure out which one is the true statement of the three, because it’s the third one. Now, cleaning my toilet is my favorite chore but it is not something I enjoy. It just happens to be the chore I dislike the least.

So by nature of it being the least negative number, it is my favorite chore. But it gives me a positive way to talk about a negative experience. And a lot of job seekers have negative past experiences.

By framing it in terms of what your favorite part of that unfavored experience was, it gives you a very elegant and professional way to discuss and address negative experiences in your past in a positive and forward-looking way.

Pete Mockaitis
Yes, indeed. And so you can’t say you’re passionate about a thing you’re not passionate about, because then you’re kind of lying, and they probably know you’re kind of lying. But you could say, “Hey, my favorite part of this was that,” and it’s good and honest.

And you love, well, your favorite chore is to clean the toilet because it’s a small amount of effort for a lot of impact. A quick swish and it’s like, “Wow, that was kind of gross.” And, like, five seconds later, it’s not gross.

Steve Dalton
Smells great. Yeah, but a lot of people are uncomfortable disclosing and being authentic and saying something that’s genuinely their favorite. So they will often pivot to, “I really enjoy cleaning the toilet,” or, “I’m passionate about cleaning the toilet,” because that feels like the thing you’re supposed to say in an interview that you’re passionate about things.

But so much of interviewing is building and maintaining trust with your interviewer. And if you deliver it, “I’m passionate about cleaning the toilet” with flat affect, they’re not going to believe you. But you can say, “My favorite chore is cleaning the toilet” with flat affect as I just did, and it’s completely credible and authentic.

Pete Mockaitis
Yep, absolutely. Well, we’re going to talk a lot about what’s new, but if you could you give us maybe the one minute version of what’s the big idea, the main thesis of The 2-Hour Job Search for those who have not yet been blessed with hearing you previously.

Steve Dalton
The 2-Hour Job Search is hinged to that great concept that we prefer instructions for difficult or unfamiliar tasks rather than tips. If we are trying to bake a cake for a loved one, we look up a recipe and not a list of tips on baking a cake.

However, that was never extrapolated to the job search. That one universal source of anxiety that we all face, that ability to provide for ourselves and our loved ones. I thought back in 2008 that that was unconscionable.

How can so many career coaches be so smart and think about this for so many hours in a day, but nobody thought to put a set of instructions to do the most difficult parts that anyone can follow, regardless of who their career coach was?

So my whole career has been about bringing structure to chaos, bringing instructions to critical life tasks. I started with The 2-Hour Job Search which was specifically for the key bottleneck of job searching, which was getting that first interview with a human being.

And then my second book, The Job Closer, was similar style of frameworks and fill-in-the-blank models for doing all the other necessary tasks in the job search to make time for reaching out to strangers, asking them how they got so good at their job, and engaging with their answers as is explained in The 2-Hour Job Search. So those two are really companion pieces to one another.

Pete Mockaitis

So you have the instructions, and a key part of the instructions, which I think is sort of a light-bulb moment for many is that the name of the game is having conversations that lead you to having conversations with the right people, which lead you to interviews, as opposed to click, apply, click apply, click apply.

Steve Dalton

Absolutely. I think there is a lot of resistance to this, that concept of networking. I think the biggest one is that you’ve never been trained to network with strangers for the purpose of a job search. People just tell you to go network like it’s self-apparent and it’s totally not.

The chemical engineer in me is bred for awkwardness. And “Sell yourself and put yourself out there, and the job search is a full-time job and be confident,“ all of those things, when I try to put it into practice without really having that aptitude, were counterproductive.

And I realized there are a lot of people like me out there. They’re awkward. They’re neurodivergent. What about all of us for whom sell yourself doesn’t work? And I realized instructions are both clear and kind, to use a Brene Brown-ism.

If we can follow recipes, we should be able to bake a cake. I wanted to bring that to anyone with a library card, not just my students who happen to be able to afford MBAs and then happen to choose Duke University where I worked for 17 years in their career center.

Pete Mockaitis
All right. So we got the instructions and they’re gold, and I’ve shared these instructions with many people and I am chatting with a listener shortly. Shout out to Kai. and I’ll be discussing your instructions yet again.

But, before we get into the juicy bits of what’s new in the third edition of The 2-Hour Job Search, I want to get your hot take. As someone who provides the instructions that are great, what’s the sense of the job market in late 2026, early 2027?

Sometimes, you see terrifying things like, “I’ve clicked hundreds of jobs and I can’t get anything at all.” But other people I know have gotten them fast. It feels like an oversimplification for me to say, “Well, if you just do what Steve says, you’ll get a job fairly soon-ish.”

Is that harsh and inaccurate? Or is it kind of what you’ve been seeing with people that, “Hey, if you do the networking things, you still tend to find jobs, even in this difficult environment”?

Steve Dalton
Overview, the job search, as most people know it is terrible. It’s just as awful as everybody thinks it is. Ashby did a study last year, over several years and 34 million applications, and they found the offer rate on a single online application is 0.2%. Not 2%, 0.2%, one out of 500.

Pete Mockaitis
Five hundred, okay.

Steve Dalton
So I asked my LinkedIn followers, “How long does it take you – when all tasks are combined, searching for postings, customizing resumes, and hitting apply – how long does it take you to get an application out the door?” They said 90 minutes.

Now, quick math here. If you spend three hours a night with no holidays or weekends off, every night, it will take you 13 months at those odds just to have an 80% chance of getting an offer through an online job posting.

And this is 2025, before AI was really, really helpful at making you crank out online applications faster. That’s only going to get worse. Bots are only going to get better. I predict within six months, online applications are something that will require no active effort on the part of job seekers. And I can’t wait for that to be the case. It gives us so much time back.

But what does the job search look like when applications happen while you sleep with no active involvement of your own? So online applications are a cesspool, they are basically zero odds, but you will hear the urban legends. I equate it to playing the lottery to try to pay off your rent.

It, occasionally, works out, but it’s not a great way to do it. And it causes a lot of downstream suffering if you’re unsuccessful, which most people will be. Now, the job market for applying is terrible. The job market for networking is an arbitrage opportunity. Very few people are doing it. We’re all obsessed with online applications. In six months, I think online applications go away. There are only really three options for job searching.

There is applying online, which we’re all familiar with; there’s networking, which you’ve already heard me talk about; and there’s attracting, which is that school of thought of “Be a thought leader,” “Become an influencer in your space,” “Comment on other smart people’s insights on LinkedIn or on TikTok.”

I think that one is better than applying because, at least, you’re learning, your network is broadening. But it’s not for everybody to live such a public job search. The thing is, the most popular method is going to go away in about six months. What’s going to happen when it does?

I like to think people will, begrudgingly, embrace networking and realize, “Wait, it’s not my fault. I’ve never been taught to do this. I’ve just been told to network with no instruction beyond that.” But my real concern is despair happens. And people just throw their hands up and, “Well, if the bots don’t match me, I guess I’m just not fit to be employed.”

So my goal is really to let people know that networking, it is a skill like riding a bike or learning to swim or speaking a new language that can be learned. Get ahead of the curve. If you’re one of the few doing it right now, you are going to trounce the competition. But it is scary.

And it’s scarier the further you get in your career, because the more insight, because it took me two editions of the book to finally figure out who the target market for The 2-Hour Job Search which is embarrassing as a marketer.

I used to be a marketer for General Mills, and they said, “If you target everybody, you target nobody.” And I thought The 2-Hour Job Search was for everybody. It was only for the third edition that I realized The 2-Hour Job Search is for anyone who is or can become vulnerable and humble because that is the way you get strangers to help you with your job search, to risk their own social capital to advocate for you.

But that is not everybody in the world. Not everybody has that ability. And the more knowledge you have, the longer you’re used to teaching, the harder it is to put the learner hat back on.

So it does require vulnerability and humility to get people to bring their guards down enough to, almost irrationally, risk their own social capital to help you with your job search, but it is a skill that can be learned, and it will make you. It is a more human and humane way to go about this daunting, daunting task. You just need to be trained for it.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay, I hear you loud and clear. Networking is key in order to be competitive. Do it. And watch out for despair. So then, those who are networking are seeing fine results? Even now, things are not catastrophically, horrifically far worse than they were one to six years ago? Is that true?

Steve Dalton

Networking is harder, there are fewer jobs, more positions are being dissolved and not replaced. Furthermore, we need to talk a little bit about networking, because networking is itself a problematic term, because some people will say, “I reached out to my network and asked them if they had any positions, and they didn’t have anything for me, so networking doesn’t work.”

You could argue that, “Is that networking or not?” What I teach is something I specifically call proactive networking. It’s reaching out to people who are not expecting to have a relationship with you back. So usually strangers.

Now, it’s okay to involve people from your past, but I find it’s harder to change the urgency of existing contacts than to establish an advocacy relationship with someone who’s never known you in any other capacity as a job seeker.

I differentiate that from reactive networking. Reactive networking is my term for getting along with people you share space with. If you’re put on the same team as somebody, they’re going to expect to have a relationship with you and you back with them. That’s just cooperation. We’ve learned that. We learned that by aging, just by going through grade school, being placed on teams and our academics.

But proactive networking is a novel skill that if you aren’t taught to do it and you don’t build that muscle mass, you will just continue not knowing it for the rest of your career, and that’s terrifying.

The nice thing is you only need to learn it once and it’s there for you for the rest of your life. So networking, networking done poorly is counterproductive. Networking done properly, what I call proactive networking, is very, very predictably positive, but it requires learning a new skill, learning a new language.

It is not the “Sell yourself” networking that you may have learned in the past. It’s not the, “Open with two minutes about yourself and your accomplishments before doing an informational meeting.”

It’s, “Wait until you’re asked questions about yourself before talking about yourself because the person you’re speaking to is the star of the show.” They are the one who’s doing you the favor. So let’s feature them and ask them how they got so good at their job.

Pete Mockaitis
Yeah, certainly. Okay. So you gave us the instructions previously. I guess I’d love to know what’s new, what’s fresh, what’s updated in terms of the recipe? We know who the recipe is for. Got to be vulnerable and humble, and it’s nice to flag that clearly in terms of like, “This is what it’s going to take, and that doesn’t feel so good. But the quicker you can kind of get over yourself in that hurdle, the better.”

So duly noted. Then, assuming we are humbly over ourselves and we have the old recipe, the old instructions, what do we need to know now, Steve?

Steve Dalton
Excellent question. So AI has been a blessing and a curse in our job searches. We’ve been talking incessantly about AI for several years. Quick question to those of you out there listening, do you feel your job search is better because of it?

Most people I talked to would answer no. It’s worse, if anything. It’s harder now, now that everybody else is using AI. And that, to me, is a sign that maybe this is insanity that we’re engaging in, by doing the same things over and over and expecting a different result.

AI is not the silver bullet we hoped it would be. We gave it every shot. We went to how many workshops on it to learn how to apply AI to our job search. We are going back to the future as AI basically commoditizes the cost down to zero of your resumes and applications because they’ll be submitted overnight, and bots will do it for us.

We need to figure out where we’re going next. Are we going to attract people to us by being influencers? Or are we going to go to them by being networkers? So, obviously, I encourage people to be networkers.

Now, where AI is helpful, people, the job seekers tend to use AI for the wrong things and not use it for the right things. The wrong things to use it for are, incessantly, like updating your resume. Nobody is looking at the resume that closely. There is no data-based way to beat an ATF system or an online resume drop.

As much advice as you see on the internet, it is companies with vested interests who are making you very, very paranoid about what you’re doing to your resume before hitting submit, but there’s no data that it leads to offers, and that’s the ultimate goal of this exercise.

Pete Mockaitis
Well, let’s have a timeout on that. So, I mean, I love a good resume. Call me old fashioned. Am I hearing you say that there’s no gaming or finessing the applicant tracking systems, ATSs, with key words or including this paragraph versus that paragraph in your resume, like there’s studies or evidence suggesting that none of those efforts do anything for you?

Steve Dalton
Let me put it another way. There is data that shows that being one of the first 10 or 20 applicants to apply has a much stronger impact on your likelihood of being selected than optimizing your keywords. Because if you’re the hundredth one who applies, the recruiter who is looking through that batch, like ATS systems are surprisingly low tech, you’ve got a human being, a recruiter.

Now the recruiter is measured on how quickly they close these open positions. So their incentive is to be fast, to satisfy, to be good enough quickly.

So they will look at the first batch of 20 and decide if there’s a good enough batch of people to move on to the next round. And if they don’t, they’ll look at the next 10 and hope to find enough to round out a full roster, and they’ll look at 10 more, but once they find a good enough batch, they’ll ship it off so they can focus on their other 14 jobs.

So they aren’t able to be really, really well trained in what elements of a resume make someone a sure thing candidate. And complicating matters, these recruiters are getting overwhelmed by bot-driven applicants, “Well, people who are clearly not interested in the job, they’re just firing out resumes ad nauseam.”

But the fairest way to go through those resumes is in the order that they were received. So my take is optimizing your resume for each online posting that you apply to is of limited value.

Pete Mockaitis
Well, it sounds like it’s counterproductive because that will take time, making you not one the top first 10 to 20.

Steve Dalton
Exactly right. And what’s funny is recruiters will complain, “Oh, there’s so much AI in these applications.” And how do they respond to that? “Well, we get overwhelmed with applications. We got to take this posting down, suddenly and without warning.”

And when postings come down suddenly and without warning, job seekers think, “I need to use AI so I can submit before the posting goes away.” So recruiters get more and more AI-based applications. So it’s a death spiral.

Now, where investing in your resume matters is when you have an advocate at a company and they say, “Send me your resume and I’ll pass it along to the hiring manager.” Now it matters. Now put some thought and time into it to make sure that your advocate doesn’t get burned by you having a typo or by you using a resume that’s clearly for a different job function or a different company.

My best practice is have one resume for each job function that you are targeting. Do your best on it, but take all of that extra time and stress and anxiety, and every time you edit your resume, you introduce the risk of typos and grammatical errors, that can get you kicked out of certain processes.

Take that time and port in networking and just do your networking first. It’s only going to be 15 minutes a day if you use The 2-Hour Job Search recipe that I provide in the books. Just do that 15 minutes first, and you can spend however much time with the remainder of your day applying online if you’d like, or building your brand on LinkedIn, or going to a movie and spending time with loved ones.

I think all of those are better uses of time. Just make sure that the bottleneck of the process, waiting for strangers to get back to you to see if they’re going to advocate for you, do that first. That’s Operations Theory 101. If you have a bottleneck, move it to the front of your process because that limits the rate at which you make progress.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay, then, so AI, where can it be useful for us?

Steve Dalton
So AI can be incredibly useful on the very, very front end of this process, making something called the LAMP list. The LAMP list is the fundamental centerpiece of the first third of the two-hour job search. It is prioritization.

You only have a finite number of hours and pain tolerance to devote to networking with strangers, this scary thing that you probably never had to do before with any sort of rigor or training behind you. So I want to be very mindful. We need to maximize every minute that you put into this.

But to maximize our benefits, before we spend dozens of hours networking with strangers. Let’s spend 40 minutes thinking who we should even be reaching out to.

And so we brainstorm a large list of potential candidates. We find three pieces of data which are easy to find and predictive of success. We rank them in order, and then we fiddle with those numbers until we get the six that we feel best about, being our first batch of outreach.

This is inspired by the TV show “The Bachelor.” It’s better to be the bachelor on “The Bachelor” than one of 25 contestants on “The Bachelor.” But AI is incredibly good at helping you brainstorm companies, better even than classic tools like Pitchbook or Crunch Base. Tell it, “Here are two or three companies I’m super excited about,” and tell it why. “Give me 10 more like those,” and it will give you 10 more like those.

And then you just give it feedback, “I like these three that you suggested, but I don’t like these other seven. I like these three because of their geography, and because they’re more in the growth phase. And those seven, I don’t want to live there, and they’re more established and bigger companies. I’d rather work for smaller companies.”

And it’s really good at reactive brainstorming. It can keep pitching you ideas so you can swipe left on the ones you like, or on the ones you hate, and right on the ones that you like, and you can get to 40 employers, which is the bare minimum for a LAMP list in about 10 minutes, just reactively reacting to whatever AI spits out at you.

Pete Mockaitis
I dig that a lot. So the AI is, and that’s perfect, I think, in terms of, that is my best experience with AI, is I give it a boatload of context and say, especially for book recommendations, like, “I’m looking for a book that’s going to help me this, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.” And I was going in all this detail, it’s like, “Give me my top five options and your rationale.”

And I was like, “Number one sounds close, but I want it more like this. Do it again.” And then, sure enough, it’s great because, like, the key words only take you so far. So that’s awesome. I dig that.

And so I’m imagining, you know, you could just use multiple models. I mean, sometimes, I geek out on what do I see on Arena.ai or Artificial Analysis to see who’s on top at the moment. But this is so quick, you could probably just do it in five different models and just rock and roll.

Steve Dalton
The shorter time you spend making this list, the easier it is to walk away from. And this is meant to be like a balance sheet, for my accounting friends out there. It’s a snapshot in time. Best used when you focus on no more than three sectors that you just inherently or organically enjoy learning about.

And let’s say you talk to a couple people who are product managers at video game companies, and you decide, “Actually, that’s not me anymore.” You just dissolve the list and remake it from scratch with another sector that you think would be more interesting based on what you’ve now learned.

So it’s not meant to be something that you update. It’s not meant to be open on your laptop at all times. It’s something you do once, you see your top six and you close it, and you only look it up when it’s time to move down to company number seven or when you realize your goals have changed.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay, cool. Well, also tell us, if we operate with the two-hour job search instructions that we’ve heard before, or I recommend you go listen to again, what else is new or different or can be enhanced in 2026, 2027?

Steve Dalton
I think it’s important to note the outreach email is now the seven-point email. But with the proliferation of AI spam messages, especially on LinkedIn. LinkedIn has gotten harder to operate in, in a pleasant way. With the proliferation of spam emails, it is more important to be precise in your outreach to strangers, to not resemble the AI spam that’s out there.

So the seven-point email is a very specific and simple fill-in-the-blank template with no fluff. It is, you know, all killer, no filler. But it is a fill-in-the-blank exercise that basically is so short and so targeted, every word, every sentence counts, but that differentiates it from the spam email that you’re used to seeing and deleting immediately without reading.

So there’s no, “Hope you’re well.” There’s no niceties. It’s rooted in the concept that most people don’t want to help you in your job search. You will encounter three different types of contacts.

There are curmudgeons who will never respond under any circumstance. They’re not the worst ones because they’re clear about not being helpful. There are obligates. They are the worst ones you’ll encounter because they want to appear to be helpful, to not lose face, but they don’t actually want to risk their social capital on your behalf, which is devastating because they give you negative return on investment. They take your hope and crush it.

The majority of the help you get in your job search comes from boosters. They’re about 20% of the population. But they are beautiful people and the great thing about them is they’re very easy to reach efficiently.

They don’t need to be sold on why you’re a good person for them to talk to. They just need to know you need help. So there’s a great study in Predictably Irrational that finds you’re just as likely to get a stranger’s help to move a couch if you offer them $0 as if you offer them $50.

But if you offer them $5, you’re far less likely to get a person’s help moving a couch. They call that in the study switching from social norms to market norms. The reason you move a person’s couch for $0 is it’s a good deed. The reason you move someone’s couch for $50 is that’s a good day’s wage.

But once you introduce $5, it’s not a good deed plus $5. The good deed goes out the window, it’s purely an hourly wage calculation. So there were a couple of aberrations that were starting to happen. I think job seekers today are so terrified of making mistakes that they tended to take exact job titles from LinkedIn, put it into their outreach messages, especially in the title.

Your SENIOR PRODUCT MANAGER experience at Waymo, with senior product manager, in all caps, or is capitalized, where it looks like it’s a merge letter that you just copied and pasted their job title and put it in the title. We want these things to look more casual than super formal because super formal is what AI tends to opt for.

So writing a message that is targeting boosters exclusively, or primarily, using language that brings down the temperature on your ask, this is just one person asking a professional how they got so smart at their job.

And then living through with their promise. This is about the readers’ insights and knowledge that they’d be willing to share with a stranger out of the goodness of their heart. It’s a very specific email, but it has a very, very strong impact with our target audience, and it works just as well now as it did five or ten years ago.

There will always be boosters out there. We just aren’t trained to find them.

Pete Mockaitis
I love it. Well, Steve, could you give us a rundown? So we got seven points, you say, in this message. Could you first – I’ll put you on the spot – give us a rundown demo of what straight-up a full text of such a message could sound like? And then highlight the seven points from that.

Steve Dalton
Yes. Subject would be your product management experience at Waymo. The body would be, “Hi, Mark, I’m Becca, a fellow MBA,” and in parentheses, (Duke, Class of 2028). “Do you have some time to chat about your product management experience at Waymo? Your insights would be greatly appreciated because I’m trying to learn more about product management in the autonomous vehicle space. Best regards. Becca.” So that is the email.

Pete Mockaitis

There’s seven points in there? There are so few words. Seven full points.

Steve Dalton
Yes, exactly. And that’s one of the points. Keep it short. Short emails. Allow short responses. They’re easier to scan. It’s easier for people to figure out what the point is.

Pete Mockaitis
And it’s easy to say yes to. Like, if I see paragraphs, I just go, “Ugh.” It’s, like, “Maybe later.”

Steve Dalton
It’s funny because I’ll get a lot of pushback from job seekers who say, “I can’t send these messages. I don’t want to impose on people.” Emails this short are not imposing. It’s those long emails, especially ones where you tout your own background, the cover letter style emails, where you’re telling someone why you’re so great when they did not ask for that email.

That’s where you get into problems. This is a very reader-focused email. There’s almost nothing about you, the sender, and that’s by design. Because this conversation is not going to be about you, the sender. It’s going to be about the reader.

And we are going to honor that promise. We will talk about ourselves when asked and not before. We can put a shortcut to our LinkedIn profile at the signature line of our email. But before that, like, we are a cipher. We are whatever they want us to be. That is fine.

So the other points. Make sure you make your ask in the form of a question, ending in a question mark, not a statement ending in a period. Keep these short, under 75 words. The body of the one I just went through is about 50.

Categorize your interest. So tell them without telling them what other companies you’re likely speaking to, so they know this is probably not your first conversation in this space. So you’re going to know what you’re talking about. That is the most important one of all, is just have that category, that product management in the autonomous vehicle space.

They can probably assume you’re also looking at Lucid Motors, Argo AI, Polestar. Great! And you didn’t have to put them on the spot by saying, “Here are the companies I’m also talking to.” You gave them the category. They can infer from there.

State your commonality to them first. So you might not have gone to their school, but you share a degree with them, potentially. And if you don’t share any commonality with them, you skip that one. But the more senior they are, the more I’d want you to Google them to see if you can find a media reference that was made about them, an interview they appeared in.

Pete Mockaitis
Well, I mean, if I may, AI could help you there, too.

Steve Dalton
Absolutely, it can. So it’s great at research and great for prepping for these meetings as well. Put their experience into your own words. This is the newest and seventh point. So if they are a senior product manager, don’t ask about their SENIOR PRODUCT MANAGER experience where senior product manager is capitalized.

It’s still product management experience, “Can you tell me about your product management experience?” I know they’re a senior product manager, but to call that out very specifically makes it look like this is a job search. A little bit too on the nose, a little bit too obviously. But show the confidence that you can put their experience into your own words.

Pete Mockaitis
And I’m curious, are you better off with email or LinkedIn nowadays?

Steve Dalton
You are better off with LinkedIn Group messages, specifically. Best kept secret in the job search, and LinkedIn is aggressive about trying to take away that option from you. So they recently offered everybody a free year of career premium. The problem with career premium is it only gives you five in-mails per month, per calendar month. And it will charge you an in-email to send a message to a fellow group member.

Now to send a message to a fellow group member, you’ve got to look them up in the group directory itself and then send them a message. If you are a proud basic member, like I am, I’m proudly basic in a lot of ways, but if you’re a proud basic LinkedIn member, you can do that free 15 times per calendar month.

And that happens to be the best way to get in touch with boosters, people who are predisposed to be boosters, because you share this affinity group. They didn’t have any obligation to respond to you so they’re probably doing it because they want to engage with you and want to help where they can.

When you reach out to someone at their work address or even their alumni address, there’s a higher than average instance that they’re obligates. They’re responding because work might be checking their email or because they don’t want to lose face because they’re supposed to be a good alum but they really don’t want to do this.

So LinkedIn Group messages are your best bet. A direct email, ideally, a lifetime email from an alumni database, but second to that, their direct work email, which you might get from a Prospeo.io or a hunter.io. There are tons of services that will help you guess professional emails. That’s your second best bet.

LinkedIn Connection requests are great follow-up attempts, but they are terrible first attempts because there’s no graceful way to follow up on them, and people tend to accept them and never reply, or they tend to ignore them because they don’t know you. And you only get to customize three of those per calendar month now. So group messages are your best bet.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. So to be clear, this is a LinkedIn in-mail message to an individual who happens to be in a LinkedIn Group with you, is what you mean by group messages? One to one, but they are another person in the group with you?

Steve Dalton

Yes, it is not an in-mail unless you have premium, and then you will be charged an in mail for it.

Pete Mockaitis
Oh, it is not an in-mail.

Steve Dalton
If you are a proud basic member, it is something totally separate. You get 15 of them instead of five.

Pete Mockaitis
Oh, it doesn’t even call it an in-mail when you are in the group with them.

Steve Dalton

Yes, it is a quirk of LinkedIn, but it has been something they’ve offered for a long time and it is just so incredibly useful and free, which I love.

So join all the big LinkedIn Groups – the Harvard Business Review Group, the TEDx Talk discussion group. I’m members of plenty of groups that I don’t really engage in. I just know that there are a lot of people who tend to be job seeking in these groups. And so it gives me free access to message people that I want to get in touch with.

Pete Mockaitis
And I don’t want to get too hung up on the technicalities, but it sounds like this is a nuance that matters tremendously in terms of, like, your response rate could be decimated if you’re, you know, trying it a bit differently.

So I am finding a person who I share a group with, and then just sending the message in LinkedIn, and then that just shows up to them as not an in-mail, but a message from someone who is in the group.

Steve Dalton
Yep, you don’t even need to provide a subject line. So there’s less work for you. Even better. And they know you’re not spamming them because they can click on your LinkedIn profile. They know you share this affinity group together. It really is a beautiful thing.

But, again, you’re never trained to do this. So it’s a loophole that consistently delights. It might be the single favorite thing that I get to share with all of my audiences when I go do talks at schools or even companies.

Pete Mockaitis

Well, I think, if I may, the reason we love it so much is because, one, we never knew it; two, it’s so quick and easy; and, three, it makes a big impact. I mean, that’s like the sweet, sweet nectar of podcasts right there, Steve.

Steve Dalton
Just want to provide value.

Pete Mockaitis
You nailed it. Cool. All right. Well, wow, so much good stuff. So, Steve, tell me, what is something else that is new that we got to know?

Steve Dalton
You know, we talked about earlier, there are basically three ways of job searching. I think it’s also important to dispel the myths around the term referral.

So the word referral is problematic. A lot of you are thinking, “I’ve gotten referrals before, and it hasn’t led to any interviews. Like, this thing, this whole system doesn’t work.” And it’s because the word referral itself is problematic.

Now, these three phenomena I’m about to describe are all called referrals. The first one, “I don’t have time to talk, but here’s a link. Apply through that link, and you should be good.” This is especially a popular one with Mag 7 companies like Meta and Amazon. That is a referral.

I call that an online referral. Everybody has one. They are points of parity. They’re easy to get, therefore, they don’t return that much of an investment on it.

Pete Mockaitis
But it’s more than zero, like applying blind to the posting. Okay.

Steve Dalton
Yeah, so even with that referral, everyone else has one, too. They’re awash. We want human referrals. Now some of you are thinking, “Well, Steve, I wasn’t born into the right family where my dad is buddies with the CEO at the country club.” Nor was I. I call these birthright referrals.

If you have them, you’d be a fool not to use them, but most of us don’t have them. And it’s easy to think, “Everybody else has them but me,” and really nobody does. We are all looking. And those people are probably not in the job search very often because they just go from kind of nepotistic position to position.

So I call them birthright referrals. We can’t go back in time and change who we were born to and what income bracket. So use them if you have them, but I think a lot of people overvalue them. Just because you knew someone in your past doesn’t mean they’re going to be helpful or advocate for you.

The best thing you can do as a job seeker is go for earned referrals. That’s my term for someone who’s a first-gen college student who convinces someone who is doing product management at one of their dream companies to use their own social capital to introduce this first-gen college student to another product manager who may have a job opening.

That is an earned referral. You demonstrated actual skills that will be useful in any job. So why wouldn’t you put that person to the front of the line for an interview, that you can teach them what they need to know because they already demonstrate the ability to learn a critical skill for any position? But it’s important to note we are targeting earned referrals.

So when we get into these informational meetings, the final third of the book, there’s no single question you can ask a stranger to turn them into an advocate. So the important thing to note is that this is a professional intimacy-building algorithm that I call TIARA.

The best you can do from a stranger is turn them into an acquaintance. But you can’t take an acquaintance and ask them a single question that will turn them into a mentor either. The best you can do for an acquaintance is turn them into a subject matter expert.

So that’s where I recommend the Trend followed by Insight questions of the TIARA framework, T-I-A-R-A. Trend and Insight are the first two questions. Trends are macro questions. Insights are more personal.

That would be inappropriate to open with. Like, “What’s been your best professional decision so far and why?” A bit too intimate to start with, but it’s great after a big macro question, like, “What trend is most impacting your space right now, in your opinion?”

So Trend and Insight questions make people think creatively. They ask them for superlatives, they search their brain and genuinely engage with you. Now they’re feeling like a subject matter expert. And from subject matter expert, you can definitely convert someone to potential mentor by asking them Advice, Resources, and Assignment questions to wrap up the experience.

And that’s laid out in the third edition of The 2-Hour Job Search but really laying it out, it’s a customer journey that we’re trying to fit into one 30-minute meeting. So I disagree with, “Oh, I only need 15 minutes of your time.” It takes time to build this intimacy.

I also deeply, deeply disagree with the feedback that, “At the end of your informational ask, who you should speak to next?” There are lots of pieces of advice I wish would die in a fire, but that one more so than pretty much all of the other ones, because it’s a quick way to cheapen the discussion you just had.

Asking this person how they got so smart at their job and then ending it by implying that they weren’t helpful enough, or maybe this was a plan all along and you didn’t really care about their insights. You were just looking to get introduced to someone more important.

And, furthermore, you didn’t get a chance to get consent from your coworker to share their name with a stranger. So there’s so much bad about this advice. You will be going back and asking for those referrals later, but at the end of the informational is the worst time to do it.

It is the rudest and cruelest time to do it, and you will make the person who just gave you the gift of their time and knowledge lose face, which makes them not want to work with you anymore.

Pete Mockaitis
Now, Steve, there’s some passion there on this one. I can totally hear you there in that those are the vibes that I think I would feel if upon, and I felt it before. You know, it’s almost like, and I think I’m a fairly humble guy.

But if I’m really cooking with someone, right, and I’m feeling like, “You know, I really like this dude. This person’s got it going on. We’re vibing here. I really want them to succeed and win. I’m sharing the goods, the secrets, the gold.”

And then I hear, “Is there anyone else I could talk to?” That is my immediate reaction, it’s like, “Oh, sorry, I wasn’t good enough for you? With all that, that wasn’t good enough?” And so now, on the flip side, if they give you nothing good, like maybe you should ask.

Steve Dalton
I recommend, there’s a middle ground here and TIARA builds it right into the framework. That resources question is always the same. I call it the pivot question. It is always this, “What resources do you recommend I look into next?”

Pete Mockaitis
Resources.

Steve Dalton
The word resources is vague on purpose. Ideally, we’re hoping for a referral to another human being. That’s an earned referral. Some people are open with their networks. Some people may have gotten permission recently to share that person’s name.

Some people may just be excited to help you, and they will volunteer that information, “Oh, do you want to work for us? Oh, you got to go talk to Wendy. She’s looking for somebody right now. I’ll make the intro for you.”

But the key is you didn’t ask them, put them on the spot, make them lose face by saying, “Who should I speak to next?” If they weren’t ready to volunteer Wendy’s name, that would be very awkward.

So I put that at about 20% of cases when you ask the pivot question, “What resources should I look into next?” About 20% of the time, you’ll get someone who just volunteers a name to you.

The other 80% will say, “What sort of resources are you looking for?” And that’s when I recommend pivoting in the other direction, “What’s the best 10 minutes of research you do in a given day or week to stay current on your space? Is there a monthly, daily, weekly newsletter that you find most helpful, and why? Is there a conference that you prioritize attending each year and why do you find it so helpful?”

But it’s really about keeping this person’s trust and advocacy because, ultimately, you’re going to need them to risk their own social capital to make an introduction for you on your behalf.

Pete Mockaitis
So good. Thank you, Steve. Well, now can we hear about a favorite quote, something you find inspiring?

Steve Dalton
I’ve been reading a lot of Dungeon Crawler Carl lately, as many of my listeners out there might be. I’ve found it very inspirational, “You will not break me,” whenever you’re going through that tough period. And I think a lot of us are going through that tough period right now.

We don’t know how we can possibly tackle the beast of job searching. It will not break you. You just have not been trained for this yet.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. And a favorite book?

Steve Dalton
Man, we already mentioned Dungeon Crawler Carl, so I’ll just recommend the entire set. And I also really enjoyed Recursion recently. So I like a good time travel mystery. So those would be the ones I’d keep an eye out for.

Pete Mockaitis
And a favorite tool?

Steve Dalton
Claude used well. Use it well. Use it for what it’s good at, which is helping you figure out what you want to do, helping you understand, “What are 10 projects I would be expected to do if I were hired as a product manager for Waymo?” And see if that work appeals to you. That may help you learn you don’t even want to be a product manager.

Like, use Claude, challenge your creativity. It can help you prep for these informational meetings, “What are 10 trends that I need to be aware of? What are 10 pieces of jargon I should be aware of before talking to some product manager who works at Waymo?”

Use it for those less obvious things. Use it for things that are stressing you out and have you stuck, that email that’s tough to word, that concept you’re having trouble putting a finger on, that analogy that you’re just really struggling to come up with. But don’t use it for cover letters. Don’t use it for resumes. It’s not good at that.

Pete Mockaitis
All right. And is there a key nugget you share that seems to connect and resonate with folks, they quote back to you often?

Steve Dalton
A big discussion on the green button paradox. The green button paradox is my term for a thought experiment. I asked career coaches and job seekers alike, “Let’s say that there is a green button you can push.” And, please, join this conversation. I’d love to know your inputs and takes.

Let’s say there’s a green button you can push that will instantly download into your brain all of the whys of networking, all of the benefits from a statistical perspective in terms of your job search, all of the what’s of networking, like how to do a good informational, how to do the TIARA framework, how to write a good seven-point email, how to follow up on those meetings optimally to maximize the conversion to an interview, so it takes away all the risk of embarrassment of doing these wrong.

Pete, the only catch of it is, if you push the button, a batch of outreach initially goes out to your top six, and people expect you to show up at those networking meetings. Data shows that this is going to help you get jobs.

But what percent of job seekers do you think push the button?

Pete Mockaitis
Well, for me, I 100% would push it. So that’s me. But what do I think about most? I think they would say 70-ish percent.

Steve Dalton
The career coaches that I sampled in a recent webinar were between 20 and 30 percent thought would push the button. And that, to me, is very sobering.

Pete Mockaitis
So they thought that 20-30% would choose to push the button. What are you seeing in your survey so far of the percent who would push the button?

Steve Dalton
Job seekers had something pretty similar. It seemed like even the job seekers in this particular session were between 20 and 50 percent. So implying that under half would push the button.

I get it. Like, we are a generation now that is entering the workforce that grew up on screens with less in-real life play. A lot of our socialization is networking. We’ve worked from home for many years, even though it wasn’t our choice.

So I get all of that exhaustion, but the stakes are so high right now. So, to me, the reason this paradox has got me so obsessed is, like, I’m all about programming the button to be better at making the mechanics of outreach and networking easier and more effective.

But I think we all need to ask ourselves, “What is holding us back from pushing the button and how do we get over that?” How do we break down and formalize and institutionalize, maybe at the high school level, even, this fear? Because it’s a lot easier to learn to swim when you’re a toddler than when you’re 40 years old. You just haven’t built up the fear of it.

And I think higher education really needs to take a look at the green button paradox and figure out, “What are we doing to solve the people’s unwillingness to push the button, even though we can prove to them, this is only good for you? This is solving that pain point that you say you want solved, but it seems like the barriers.”

And it’s important to note that our brains have been, for hundreds of thousands of years, wired to protect us. It is doing the same thing to job seekers right now. Every time it comes up with a reason why now is not the right time to network, that is your brain trying to keep you safe from psychological harm.

But we need to have the wherewithal, the agency to tell our brain, to Marie Kondo our brains and say, “Thank you for your service. I know you were trying to do me a solid. The stakes here are just too high. I need to take you off autopilot right now.”

To me, the green button paradox is the next big challenge in the job search. What are we doing about getting people increasing people’s job seekers’ willingness to actually push the button if they had it presented to them? That’s, to me, the bigger challenge and that’s going to take a village.

Pete Mockaitis
And, Steve, if folks want to learn more or get in touch, where would you point them?

Steve Dalton
Follow me on LinkedIn. I have a LinkedIn Group of about 25,000 people. I answer questions from readers about once a day. There’s usually no more than a week long queue before your questions will get greenlit.

I do corporate workshops, so if you would think, “This would be helpful for our company,” please mention me to your colleagues. Steve@contact2colleague.com is my email address for workshops and talks. If you have a job search question, I’m happy to answer it. I may direct you to my LinkedIn Group for it, though, out of fairness to those already waiting in the queue.

But please engage with this material, get curious, ask me questions, challenge the material. If something I said doesn’t make sense today, I’d love to hear your perspective because that’s how this recipe gets better over time.

Pete Mockaitis
All right. And do you have a final challenge, or, kind of sounds like we covered them, but do you have a final challenge or call to action for folks looking to be awesome their jobs?

Steve Dalton
Stay curious. This is a life skill you only need to learn once, like riding a bike. It will be with you for the rest of your life. It will help you get promoted. Keep your job when there are layoffs, find more community at work. The benefits will never stop paying off. Bite the bullet now, learn it now, especially before everybody else has no choice but to learn it.

Pete Mockaitis
All right. Steve, thank you.

Steve Dalton
Absolutely, my pleasure. Thanks for having me back.

1090: How to Get Recruiters to Compete for You with Madeline Mann

By Podcasts No Comments

Madeline Mann shares insider tips and strategies for landing exciting new career opportunities.

You’ll Learn

  1. The resume mistake high achievers make
  2. The simple tweak that dramatically nets you more inbound opportunities
  3. The interview hack that makes you sound like an expert

About Madeline

Madeline Mann is an HR & Recruiting leader who spun her insider knowledge of the hiring process into an award-winning career coaching empire, called Self Made Millennial. Mann is now known for turning job seekers into Job Shoppers, to enable any professional to land high-paying job offers for seemingly unattainable roles. Her clients have landed at companies such as Netflix, Google, Goldman Sachs, Deloitte, NBC Universal, Amazon, and more. She lives in Los Angeles.

Resources Mentioned

Thank you, Sponsors!

Pete Mockaitis
Madeline, welcome!

Madeline Mann
Thanks for having me.

Pete Mockaitis
Well, I’m excited to chat. You’ve got so much good stuff on YouTube and elsewhere, talking career searching, job hunting, interview, answering. So, we’re going to talk a bit about some of the goods in your book, Reverse the Search: How to Turn Job Seeking into Job Shopping. Can you share with us, as you’ve spent all this time working in this field, what’s one of the most surprising and fascinating discoveries you’ve made or the advice you share that folks are genuinely shocked to hear and they thought it was the other way around?

Madeline Mann
Well, when I worked in human resources, I was the one who ran every hiring process. And something stood out to me is that it wasn’t the candidates who, necessarily, had the perfect background or the Ivy League education that made hiring managers trip over themselves to get them a position. There were certain candidates who were able to use certain approaches that allowed them to make the company compete for them.

So, they would say things like, “Oh, we need to hurry up the hiring process so we can get this person.” And, even, I worked at companies where we didn’t have these giant Google budgets, right? We had tight budgets, and we would go over budget to get certain candidates, even though they might not be, like I said, the perfect-on-paper candidate.

And so, that is the thing that really sparked the idea for this book, is that people don’t realize that on the other side of the table, these companies, when they find a candidate that they really like, they will compete for that person. And if you can find the ways to start enticing these companies, even if you’re a career-changer or an unconventional candidate, that they will go above and beyond for you.

Pete Mockaitis
You know, this is funny, and this is reminding me of the most random of things. I’m thinking about the book, Neil Strauss, The Game, talking about pickup artists, and they try to adopt this mindset, like, “No, no, no, no, I am the prize. I am a high value,” whatever. And they use a number of tactics, which aren’t so reputable, and I don’t imagine you want to neg your employer, your prospective employer, or maybe you do, Madeline.

Madeline Mann
You don’t want to neg.

Pete Mockaitis
I mean, “Google is okay, I guess. It’s no Open AI.”

Madeline Mann
Yeah, exactly. And I think that that’s actually kind of a really interesting misconception because they think, when I say, “Ooh, reverse the search. Go job shopping,” that suddenly you have this air of entitlement and all of that or negging, as you say, where you’re kind of taking company down a peg of, “I have other options. Like, what do you have to offer me?” It’s actually not that way at all.

It’s more about understanding exactly what the company needs and kind of taking your ego out of it, not talking about the details of your complicated career journey, but instead, focusing on, “Okay, what does the company need? How can I fill that need?” And knowing that you are the right person, you can make it happen, showing them you can make it happen, but also having this strategy where you are having opportunities come to you in a way that you don’t have to move into desperation mode.

Pete Mockaitis
And I’m curious, how does one, in fact, truly learn what they need? Because sometimes the job post, job description is kind of thin. It’s kind of generic. It might even be written by AI. I’ve had a buddy who does interviews, he’s like, “They said they wanted all these things in the job description, but then when I started using the terms, they seemed to not understand them in the interview. What’s going on here?”

Madeline Mann
Unreal. I totally get it. And, yes, so you’re right. The first place to look is the job description. That’s kind of where you start. And if you’re not able to unearth enough there, you can start also doing some research. If it’s a marketing role, sign up for the company’s email lists and look on their website. If it’s a customer success role, report a ticket or do something like that. If it’s a product role, interact with their product or see even how they talk about the product on the website.

If it’s human resources, read other job descriptions, read Glassdoor. Like, there’s just a million ways to actually explore a company and understand what is the state of that role in some ways. Now, really, where you understand what a company needs and is looking for is in the interview. Now, sometimes you can get around that by doing informational interviews ahead of time, talking to employees, but, really, the key is no one’s expecting you to come into an interview process being like, “Boom! Here’s exactly what you need.”

But what you can do for the first interview is do what I call a T-chart, which is essentially where you were to take the job description and you would match each of your past experiences to what is on that job description. And if there’s anything you’ve ever done, any skills you have that don’t meet things on that T-chart, I don’t want you to talk about it, unless you’re asked about it. But, too often, we volunteer additional information.

If I’m going into a car dealership, and I say the most important things are the color of the car and the size of the cup holders, do not tell me about the engine and the trunk space, right? So, that’s really the idea here. And then as you go into later interviews, you’re asking really good questions to where, if you were to land the job or had to start the job tomorrow, you would ask questions almost like a consultant, where you’ve understand the state of the projects you’d work on, what are their tools, and you could actually start to build a plan of how you would execute that.

Pete Mockaitis
I like that a lot. And that car example really resonates in terms of when sales folks don’t give you what you want to know, it’s frustrating and annoying. It’s like, “I want to know the price and I don’t want to know the history of your founder.”

It kind of ruins, it kills a lot of the excitement real quick. And so, likewise, I could see that we, as a job seeker, might be doing that. It’s like, “Well, no, no, no, I did a really cool project. I got a really big impact. And so, you got to know about it.” And it’s like, “Yeah, well, that’s cool, but that’s not actually what we’re into over here.”

Madeline Mann
Well, what most people do on their resume is that their resume is their best accomplishments. And I would like to challenge your audience to stop doing that. Stop putting your best accomplishments, unless what you did in your most recent role is very perfectly in line with the exact role you’re going for next, then that makes sense.

But if the role is slightly different, which a lot of high achievers tend to pivot roles that are a little bit different, they want to learn something new, so it’s fairly common to go to a different role that’s maybe, you know, just a parallel role, you should start thinking about, “Okay, let me prioritize my accomplishments of what is most relevant.”

And you may delete the biggest, juiciest project you worked on. Let’s say you had a role where you did tons of different things. You’re going for a project manager role, but one of the things you did is you closed a $3 million deal with Pepsi. Okay, that’s a business development accomplishment. That is not a project management accomplishment. That fabulous deal is not going to make it onto your resume.

And people, sometimes they’re mourning their past job experience because they say, “Ooh, but it was so good. I was their champion at everything.” If there were project management elements of that project, sure, share those. But that accomplishment itself is distracting.

Pete Mockaitis

Yes. mourning is the word in terms of, “I worked so hard on this. I poured so much of my blood, sweat, and tears, effort into it. And now it doesn’t even serve me here?” And I guess the truth is it does not. And sharing it will make it serve you even less. It can be counterproductive. And, especially, as I think about resume space as the line as the fundamental unit of currency there. And maybe you can give a quick hot take on how long can our resumes be?

Madeline Mann
Yes, there are so many opinions about how long a resume should be, and I will put it to rest. It doesn’t necessarily matter how long your resume is, but it should only have extremely relevant information. And when you go through the glory formula, which is in the book, Reverse the Search, I’ve seen so many people where their resume shrinks, and it does shrink to one page.

And that is the interesting challenge of, if you kind of challenge yourself to do it to one page, and definitely do it to two pages, you’ll realize, “Wow, I put a lot of things on that resume that didn’t need to be there.” I put that I was CPR certified to do an accounting role. I don’t need to put that there. So, there’s just so many things that we need to take another look at, because more information is not more helpful.

Pete Mockaitis
Well, to this, we’ll zoom out in a moment, but you just keep saying enticing things, I can’t let go. So, CPR certified, understood, that’s not really relevant. Often, a resume will have a section sort of like interests or hobbies or whatever. And some would say, “Oh, that’s kind of nice.” They can get a little bit of a picture of your personality on, like, one line. What do you think about that?

Madeline Mann
I like it. I think it’s good because people hire people, okay? So, that line is really a moment for you to connect with the interviewer and it’s not guaranteed. Now here’s a guaranteed way to waste that space. If you say generic things like, “I like travel,” “I like to try new restaurants,” “I like to spend time with my family,” things that are, literally, just so foundational that there’s nothing to hold onto there.

What if, instead, you say, “I’m obsessed with Thai food,” “My favorite place to travel is Fiji,” “I have four sons.” Right? Like, saying something about where it’s specific, where, if I also have a bunch of sons, I might reach out to it, or, “I love Fiji too,” or, “Thai food is great,” like, blah, blah, blah.

Now, there’s no guarantee that the person on the other end is going to connect with any of those things, but it’s guaranteed they’re not going to connect with them if they’re hyper-generic.

Pete Mockaitis
“Oh, that’s the craziest thing. I also enjoy sunshine, Madeline. That’s crazy.” Okay. Well, we’re having fun here. Maybe let’s zoom out and, perhaps, could you share with us a story of someone who really internalized this mindset shift? They did some different things and saw a cool result because of that.

Madeline Mann
Absolutely. I think about one of my clients, Brittany. So, she was having trouble in the job search. She was very well qualified for the roles and she had a human resources background, which you’d think, “Oh, she hires people. She knows the behind-the-scenes.” But it’s wild how job searching is a completely separate skillset from actually being good at your job.

And so, she was kind of struggling to get interviews, and it all changed where, first of all, I think a lot of us really underestimate the value of LinkedIn. She started getting outreaches on LinkedIn when she optimized it, right? Doing the right things on the profile. And I do go into depth in that in Reverse the Search.

Another thing is she went through an interview process, got to the very end and was rejected. And I think this is really important for people to hear right now because a lot of my clients get rejected. But I’ve been called the Comeback Coach because a lot of them still land offers at companies that reject them. And I think that this is a really important learning for people, is that a rejection is not the end of the road.

If you’ve had an interview with a company, you have networked with them. You now have a relationship, and they have actively shown you with their time, with their effort, that they value you. So, you have to put that in your pocket, and say, “That’s a win for me.” So, this is what Brittany did. I worked with her to say, “Okay, you had a great relationship with this hiring manager. Let’s keep cultivating it.”

So, I helped her to, like, continue the relationship. We also got what I call kind of like decoy offers, like, I try to get clients even offers that they don’t want, and then bring those offers to the employers that you’re really excited about. Tell them about it. And that’s what she did. She was like, “Hey, I have this offer. I’m getting farther in this interview process. Do you guys have any open roles coming up? Like, I want to work with you the most, but I have this opportunity.”

And that hiring manager was like, “We are going to have an open role in a couple months, but you know what? I’m going to push that forward and make that happen now.” Because, suddenly, everyone wants the candidate who, first of all, is building great relationships and, second of all, is highly desired in the market.

And so, she was able to then kind of speed through that, like, second round of interviews with this company, get the offer. She earned 40% more than her last salary. She told me, “I don’t even want to negotiate because this offer is so good.”

And that’s another thing, is that if you’re job shopping, if you’re using these methods through the interview process, negotiation becomes not that important because companies will nearly almost always give you the top of their range because they’re like, “Just take it. Like, please join us.” And so that’s what happened for her.

And so, I really want to emphasize that to anyone kind of going through this tough job market is, again, like, I think this is a good example of you have a lot more influence in the process than you think. People view a rejection as them being powerless, but she spun that into a massive power and landed the offer.

Pete Mockaitis
That’s cool. I like that a lot. And I have witnessed that, in my world as well, in terms of, “Oh,” I worked at Bain for a while, and they say, “They got an offer from McKinsey. So, if we want him, we better move quick.” And they do. It’s like, “We got interviews on Fridays. Well, you’re having an interview this Friday, not a month from now,” which was previously thought it would be.

And it’s true. I think, especially in, I’m thinking about Bob Cialdini, who’s on the show, talking about influence, the notion of scarcity, as well as social proof, like just human psychology here. Like, it’s sort of ambiguous, “Is this person going to be great at this role? I mean, I hope so. They seem like it. Oh, but someone else really wants them. Okay, well, there’s some validation. I guess there’s another indicator that the odds are good, they’re a winner.”

As well as scarcity, it’s like, “Oh, oh, we better move quick or we’ll lose them.” And so, what a great place to be if you are in that position and everyone else that they’re talking to is not.

Madeline Mann
Yes, exactly. Exactly right. There are psychological principles that come up there that are as old as time. And, exactly, that scarcity, that competition, and a lot of people don’t realize that budgets are malleable, timelines are malleable, like, companies will say certain things or certain ways, but companies also understand that hiring is an art just as much of a science.

And people think that companies are just inundated with exceptional talent, and that’s actually not the case. When you find someone who’s a great talent, has a great attitude, personality, skillset, you want to keep an eye on them. You do want to hire them, and you don’t take that necessarily for granted.

Pete Mockaitis
Well, let’s maybe walk through it step by step in terms of, let’s say, “All right, I got a job and it’s okay, but it’s still not quite doing it for me in terms of I’d maybe like a little bit more money, a little bit more flexibility, a little bit more cool teammates, a little bit more impact.”

You know, it’s sort of like, our jobs are fine but we have a feeling that there’s something that is substantially better out there for us. So, we say, “You know what, let’s just go for it. Let’s just start looking around.” What would you say is the step one, two, three to embarking upon job shopping as opposed to job seeking?

Madeline Mann

So, there are short-term, medium-term, and long-term options. So many job seekers hunt, right? So hunting is basically where you kind of go out, there’s a role, you try to hunt it, and it runs away. Just like hunting, right? Like, if your prey runs away, then you kind of have lost out on it, and it’s that. That’s why you need to also have farming aspects of your strategy as well.

So, if you were just now going to embark on the job search, first of all, I would start farming, first of all. Like, let’s start tilling the field. So, first of all, the most important thing is get extremely clear about what is your next career step. Too many people skip over this. They’re like, “Well, I have a lot of different skills.” I call them kind of like the mosaic job seeker, where they’re like, “I just have so many different beautiful parts of me,” which you do, but you need to get clear.

Then your messaging needs to be extremely clear on your LinkedIn profile. And then there’s likely some profession and/or industry-specific job boards or networking sites where I would get your branding, your resume, whatever it is, on those, too, because I want those to just be magnets for opportunity. A lot of my clients report over 50% of their interviews coming in just inbound. They’re not applying, just companies coming to them.

So, that’s why we say, like, “Just get yourself out there on the internet, and let those things come into you,” because, especially, if you’re employed, you don’t have a ton of time to reach out to people. So, get that branding good to go, okay? Then I want you to start warming up that network.

First of all, talking to people in your network, and then, of course, reaching out to people at certain companies. So, having a target company list where you’re starting to network there.

Now let’s focus on the hunting, right? So, let’s now look at what jobs are out there. What is actively hiring now? So that’s the reactive job search process, where you’re reacting to what’s out there on the market. And with that, we need to be quick and precise. We’re seeing a lot in the job market right now, that you do want to act quickly when a role opens because these roles are highly inundated.

But also, especially as you move up in your career, as you’re getting more advanced, focus more on relationships of, like, making sure that that resume actually gets read, versus simply just submitting it online. So that is where I would start to kind of have this multifaceted, both short-term and long-term play for your job search, to maximize your time.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. Well, so then, when it comes to some of the particulars, like, get the branding good, what perhaps are the top two or three action steps that are just tremendously useful per minute we spend on them?

Madeline Mann
Right. So, we’ll focus on your LinkedIn profile, because while I did talk about there’s other places you can do this, let’s talk about LinkedIn because that really is the number one place that recruiters are looking for talent.

Too many people think that their “About” section is important and their cover photo is important. None of those things are unimportant, but people spend so much time on those that I would say throw those out the window. Like, let’s focus on them much later. Instead, let’s focus on what is actually moving the needle of showing up in searches.

First of all, you’re probably not surprised, your headline, okay? Your headline, I think there’s two different ways to approach your headline and, too often, if you’re using AI to create it, they’re usually telling you, like, “Make a clever statement about who you serve, and stand out that way.” Here’s the problem there. I think that a clever statement is good if you’re doing a content strategy and building a business.

So maybe you might say, you know…

Pete Mockaitis
“I’m a snack marketing ninja with an emoji.”

Madeline Mann

Yeah, exactly. Exactly. Bring snacks. Yeah, snacks to everyone you know. Yeah, exactly. So, not like that. It’s better to be like digital marketing specialist in the food and beverage industry, right? Like, something like that where it’s like, “Boom! Okay, got it.” Like, that is what I’m buying as an employer, because what recruiters do is they search for keywords.

I’ve done a ton of sourcing in my career, in my recruiting. I’m highly familiar with LinkedIn’s backend of what that looks like. So, you need to make sure that you’re findable. The people who are getting all of these interviews, such as my clients, they’re not necessarily more talented than you. They’re just more easily found.

And so, we are not thinking about the SEO of your profile. So, making sure you’re getting the right keywords on there and the right elements. And people also are afraid to put it in industry because they’re afraid to pigeonhole themselves, but industry profiles, industry-specific profiles, get far more clicks and interest.

Someone who’s just in marketing versus someone who is in marketing for food and beverages, that’s completely different, more specific skillset that is going to attract more attention. So don’t be afraid to be specific.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. So, then the headline is huge because the way the LinkedIn search algorithm is operating. So, if someone is searching for a digital marketing person in food and beverage, if you have that kind of thing in your headline, then you’ll be super findable relative to not. And I guess there’s some tricky nuances in terms of, “Well, this is what I’m doing now, but I want to do something different later.” I guess that makes it tougher as to, “What do I do with that headline there?”

Madeline Mann

Yep, you can’t focus your headline on what you did in the past. It has to be what you want to do next. Yes.

Pete Mockaitis
Or, what you want to be doing. Because, like, you’re not like, “If I’m a digital marketing specialist in food and beverage, but I want to be a digital marketing specialist for video games, I cannot say that I am that right now, though I want to be that.”

Madeline Mann
Well, here’s the thing. We always have to put ourselves in the mind of the employer, okay, “How can I be employable in video games? Well, I should start, you know, maybe doing some pro bono work for an indie video game shop, right, or something like that. Or even create my own projects.” And you need to build that experience even if it’s just a few hours a month.

And then you need to claim it on your headline because it is actually unkind to put in your headline, “I worked in food and beverage,” and then someone contacts you in food and beverage, and be like, “No, I’m not pursuing roles in food and beverage.” It’s just like an unnecessary piece of information that you’re now attracting the wrong person.

It’s more kind to say, you know, “Video games,” and then you’re attracting that opportunity and you can show them how you’ve been upskilling in that industry, how you have been an immense student of that industry. And so, now you’re attracting the right opportunities. That is more kind because now it’s easier for companies to match up to you properly versus you sending these mixed signals into the world.

Pete Mockaitis
And maybe I’m just getting a little bit hung up. So, then in this scenario we’ve dreamt up together, with the headline, “I’m a digital marketing person in food and beverage. I want to be a digital marketing person in video games,” what do I do with that headline?

Madeline Mann
I would put video games. I wouldn’t put food and beverage.

Pete Mockaitis

Okay. So, then I guess I’m a little worried then in this world, it’s like, if my boss sees this, like, “Hey, man, what?”

Madeline Mann
Yeah, oh, that’s true. So, if you’re currently employed, you’re right, I think that would raise some serious eyebrows. So, I would, in that case, remove industry. Remove industry from your headline. But you really should be showing some video game expertise on your profile. It could be that you write an article on LinkedIn. It doesn’t matter if there is one person reading it. Your brother-in-law is the only one who reads it or something like that. It doesn’t matter.

It really is just about, “When I get to your profile, I can tell that he is extremely intentional about moving into this industry,” because it scares employers so much if they feel you have not done the work to make this pivot because they do not want to be a career experiment where you think, “Oh, yeah, maybe I’ll do this industry, maybe I’ll do that industry, maybe I’ll do this job title, that job title.”

They hire you, and you realize, “Ooh, actually, this wasn’t exactly what I wanted,” or, “I’m actually vastly underqualified and I didn’t actually, like, do the work myself to get up to speed of another candidate.” And then they feel really disappointed in the hire.

Pete Mockaitis

Oh, I like that a lot. So, for get branding good, we’ve got LinkedIn showing off in the headline as much as we can, what we’re after, as well as in the other places, “Hey, I posted an article,” maybe, “I I’ve done some pro bono work for a studio and that’s listed there,” and that’s cool. Tell us more about getting branding good. I was specifically interested in that notion of, “Hey, you can just go ahead and do some free work for a company there and mention it.”

And I think that that is fabulous. We had a woman on the show, Kristen Berndt, and she had a dream of working in airline baggage operations, which I thought was funny as a very specific dream and a passion of hers. Like, she read all these articles on it, and it was amazing to me.

And so, she started a blog about these matters, like, “Hey, here’s the latest rankings on baggage performance,” and her analysis of what she thinks is going on, and why United went up or down in the rankings and some new technologies they’re using. And, sure enough, like, she got the job in that career-switch area because nobody else has a blog about airplane baggage operations, “You got the job, Kristen. Congrats.”

Madeline Mann

That is a perfect example, and, yeah, exactly. It doesn’t matter how many people read that blog or anything. She was showing that she has a growth mindset, and a lot of people don’t realize that is the biggest currency of this current job market. It’s not years of experience. It’s not wisdom. It’s not tenure. It’s ability to evolve and constantly learn, because 25 years of marketing experience doesn’t actually mean anything if you’ve lived the same year of your career 25 times.

You need to be up-leveling. You need to be learning new things. And so, just like she is, she’s showing her that she is very on top of things. She is passionate. And so, exactly, I mean, I have a client, she is at Harvard PhD and was so disappointed to enter the workforce and realize that she wasn’t really desirable. She wanted to work in market research for public companies.

And so, I worked with her to tap, I have a bunch of business owners in my network, me being a business owner myself, and I had her make a list of the type of market research she was willing to do pro bono. So, she was like, “I can do an analysis of your customers in this way and that way.” So, she made a list and I sent it out to a group of business owners.

And I said, “Does anyone want to take her up on this?” So, I had a couple of business owners say, “Yes.” And now she has incredible projects on her resume. She’s showing these employers that she was able to take what she did as a researcher at Harvard. And now she actually has real-world results.

And it’s not about her breaking her back to do 60 hours a week of work. She’s probably doing four hours a week of work, pro bono. But people are spending tens of thousands of dollars, hundreds of thousands of dollars, on education, and they’re spending so many hours a week doing these things, where you could spend so much less time and money just doing a little bit of pro bono work, getting the evidence on your resume and then having the ability to talk about that.

And a lot of people aren’t doing it because it’s not the paved path.

Pete Mockaitis
You know, I like that a lot. And I’m also thinking about just showing up at events, because you learn so much so quick when you’re talking to all the people doing all the things in terms of…I’m just thinking about Podcast Movement I’ve been to over and over again. And so, if you are interested in maybe getting into the podcast world, but didn’t have a lot of experience, well, by golly, you’re going to know all sorts of things that the uninitiated were utterly clueless about, like, three days ago.

You’d get an education on what is absolutely cutting edge, modern, top-of-mind concerns for people in this space, and as well as connections right there, like, “Hey, now I know some people and who know other people. Away we go.”

Madeline Mann
Yeah, exactly. And making those connections, learning, yeah, attending those things, consuming information, and regurgitating it back. And just claim it as your own, right? If you learn something about the podcast industry, then just, like, integrate that into the questions you ask people of the podcasters, or anything like that, or, “I’ve noticed this or that.” Just really internalize these things.

And I even have a lot of my clients, as part of their interview prep, I have a very short document that people use, where people are like, “Whoa, this interview prep you tell us to do is so much more brief than the interview prep I normally do, but yet it’s highly more effective.” And one of the things I have them do that almost no one does as a preparation for their interviews is I ask them to find a podcast specifically on their profession.

And you’d be amazed. I have so many clients of, like, super niche job titles and there is like a YouTube video out there, there’s a podcast episode out here. And you know, like in podcasting, you can get incredible people saying, basically, the most rich and factual things, but it’ll have like four views, right? And so, it’s amazing what you can find out there.

So, then they’re able to take that information that either helps them to grow their mind about their profession or further confirms the things that they already felt about their profession, helps them to crystallize in interviews, and show them as more of an expert, more of a thought leader.

And, literally, just that one action has helped land a lot of my clients, job offers, because they’re like, “Whoa, I’m communicating so much better in my interviews because I sound like I really have deeply thought about the big picture of this industry and my profession because I’ve listened to some thought leaders and done that preparation.”

Pete Mockaitis
Absolutely. And I might say, while you’re at it, feel free to reach out to the podcast guests. Many of my guests have said, “I’ve heard from so many of your listeners on LinkedIn,” and they’re so wonderful. It’s like, “Well, thank you.” Thank you, listeners, for being so wonderful, and so, yeah. And, especially, if you have a real thoughtful comment, compliment, follow-up question, folks generally like that, as opposed to a fake compliment, segueing into sales pitch. We have enough of those.

Madeline Mann
Yes. And that’s the thing, is people go on podcasts, on YouTube channels, because they want to have that effort that they put into that interview be heard by the world, right? They don’t go on to hope that no one hears it. So, the fact that you are reaching out, you’re giving a compliment, that you’re asking a question, that is absolutely welcome. So that’s one of the best possible things.

Like, if you’re trying to get your foot in the door at a company, try to find these micro influencers at the company, just people who post on LinkedIn every now and then, or people who are on podcasts every now and then. They don’t have to be your hiring manager. They don’t have to be a recruiter. They don’t have to be someone in your department.

Literally, those people, if you can just listen to what they did, read their article, they’re going to be so grateful that you engaged with it, that you found it interesting, that that is such an effortless way to network. It’s crazy. And so, that is such a good way in.

Pete Mockaitis
That’s true, yes. If folks really pour some thought and effort into an article, an interview, a post, and they have, like, crickets of response, like a couple people give it a like or, “Good article, Madeline,” and that’s about it, and then there is some authentic engagement from a human being, who found that interesting and insightful, valuable, and has a follow-up question, well, it immediately provokes the answer, “Wait, who’s this person?” Like, you’re immediately interested in that person because, like, “No one else showed any interest in me. This person did. I like them and I want to know all about them.”

Madeline Mann
Yes, people think, “I have nothing to offer this person. What can I give them?” Literally, like, your interest, and even people hitting like on a post, giving comment, showing that interest, even if you have a tiny network or a tiny social media following, like I bet you, if someone was consistently sharing your podcast episodes, like you probably wouldn’t even care how big their following is. You probably just notice them over time and say, “That person is awesome. Like, I appreciate them.” And it really is quite flattering.

So, yeah, I think it’s such an important thing that, even just taking time to notice people, I say that in Reverse the Search, it’s not about knowing people. It’s about noticing people. You don’t have to have this big network, but if you’re really great at noticing people, noticing what they’re contributing to the world, what makes them great, what makes them interesting, you are going to never want for a job.

Pete Mockaitis
Well said. Well, boy, we could talk for hours. But, Madeline, could you share with us a couple of your top do’s and don’ts that we haven’t hit yet here?

Madeline Mann
First of all is, folks think that aiming lower in their job search is easier. So, like, let’s say you’re sending out resumes and none of them are hitting, you think, “Well, why don’t I just go to roles that I’m super qualified for, I’m 130% qualified for?”

What I found is that that’s actually harder to land than maybe a role that is obviously perfectly aligned with you or even a role that’s a little bit of a reach for you. Because companies are terrified that they’re going to have to pay you too much, that you are going to get the role and you’re going to get bored really quickly, you’re going to ask for a promotion, you’re going to leave until a better job comes.

And, truthfully, I’ve seen that happen a lot at companies where people say, “Oh, no, this leveling is totally fine for me.” And they prove the company right, that it was not a right fit. So, first of all, don’t aim. If you’re going to aim anywhere, aim a little bit higher instead of lower, even if you’re a career-changer. You don’t have to go to the bottom of the rung of a career ladder if you’re career changing.

Second of all, there’s this idea that keeps permeating, that is the idea that the job search is a numbers game. And, especially now that application numbers are getting higher and higher because more and more job seekers are using AI, your friends and your family will often give you terrible advice of just apply more, more, more.

And I just have, I mean, I have a bunch of examples in the book and I have hundreds more from my clients where they just shifted the way they approach things, started going after a half a dozen, maybe a dozen roles, maybe a couple dozen roles, and landing interviews at most of them. And so, when you shift your approach, you actually find that, in a world right now where everything is so impersonal, doing more impersonal things at scale is actually the slowest way to job search.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. Yes, that makes a lot of sense because you might have more numbers, but the percentage is so super-duper tiny that it’s not really worthwhile, even though, “Oh, this was easy to apply to that job.” “Yeah, that’s what the other 3,000 people said.”

Madeline Mann
Yeah, and I would say, you know, it’s so tough to sit here and give advice because all of your listeners are unique and have different situations. I would say, if you don’t have any interviews at 10% of the applications you’re sending out, there’s something wrong, okay?

So, for some of us, we are perfectly qualified for these roles, we have great companies on our resume, we’re applying within the first 24 hours, and we are landing 10%, 20%, 30%, 40% of the job opportunities. If that is your strategy and it is working, please continue. But if you’re kind of doing all those things and it’s below 10%, something’s up. And, like, probably the high-volume job search, the way you’re going about it right now is not a good approach.

Pete Mockaitis
Well, I love a benchmark number. Thank you, Madeline. That’s handy. Tell us, any final thoughts before we hear about some of your favorite things?

Madeline Mann

One of the most important things right now is the job market is challenging. It’s really the worst job market I’ve seen in my career, and I want to say that because I want to tell your listeners that it’s not in their head.

But yet, I also sit in a position where I am seeing job seekers land not only one offer, but multiple offers all the time. So, I see this firsthand. So, I just want you to know that it is possible and, really, they’re just going one step above. Like, they’re just doing maybe one more step than you are, but they’re doing it strategically.

I was talking to someone on TikTok today, where they said, “Well, what if I get rejected from a no-reply email? I guess I’m out of luck.” Job shoppers don’t stop at a no-reply emails, right? Like, I just need you to start shifting your thinking of instead of seeing obstacles, see opportunities.

Pete Mockaitis
Well, now I just can’t let that go. So, let’s say, we applied and I got a no-reply at Craft.com, and they say, “Peter, thank you so much for your interest. Unfortunately, we have chosen to move with a different candidate,” dah, dah, dah. That’s that. What do I do there?

Madeline Mann
Yeah, so if this is truly just an application, right, you have not had any sort of correspondence with the company, you could find their general email, like, the “Hello” at their website. You could find the recruiter email, you could find the hiring manager, and people are like, “But how do I know who’s the hiring manager? How do I know what their email is?”

Those things, first of all, you’re guessing. Second of all, it’s fairly easy to guess also people’s email addresses. There’s lots of tools online that can find them or, also, it’s usually their first name at the company website, or their first initial, last name. There’s a lot of ways that it’s pretty easy to figure out.

So, spend, you know, two to five minutes finding an email address, following up, saying, “Thank you so much for getting back to me. I am bummed I missed the window for this role because I was very excited. Should anything open up or should this role open up again, I want to let you know that I’m extremely interested in it, going forward, and I wish you all the best. I’ll be rooting for you from the sidelines,” something like that.

And I remember, I got an email like that once when I was hiring a role, and I would either get silence from rejection emails or hatred when I was working in recruiting because people are very sensitive when it comes to rejection.

Pete Mockaitis
They actually say that out loud. Okay. Huh?

Madeline Mann
Yes. And so, for someone to say, “Hey, you rejected me. Just a heads up. Like, you all are a top company that I’m interested in. So, I’m going to keep up with you.” That stands out. So, what did I do with her application? I put it in the future potential bucket of my ATS. When that role opened up again, she was one of the first people I reached out to. She interviewed. She even got to one of the final rounds.

So, just know that, again, where others see obstacles, you need to see opportunities. And all these people are, like, imagine me opening up the role again, not putting it online, simply interviewing some of the candidates I had already interest in, and then she gets the role, that’s the hidden job market right there.

Because I wouldn’t have opened the role again if she fit it, and I could just interview her and not have to go through all the folder all of like, you know, evaluating all these applications. People don’t realize that these are some of the ways that you’re cutting the line in the job search.

Pete Mockaitis
All right. Well, now can you share a favorite quote, something you find inspiring?

Madeline Mann
“A healthy man has a thousand wishes. A sick man has only one.”

Pete Mockaitis
All right. Thank you. And now a favorite study or experiment or piece of research?

Madeline Mann
I am a big fan of Cialdini. His book, Influence, was one that just completely transformed my life. I read it in high school, and it’s really transformed. He actually did a study, where he found that one of the best questions to ask in a job interview is, “Why did you bring me in here today? What made you feel that I was qualified to be here today?”

And he proved that that question was influential in getting the company to start rationalizing why that person is a good fit.

Pete Mockaitis
Oh, that is a great question. And it gives you valuable information, it’s like, “Oh, okay. I thought it was this other thing. I’m not going to talk about that. I’m going to talk about what you said.

Madeline Mann
“Yes, I’m going to focus on that. Yes.”

Pete Mockaitis
And a favorite book?

Madeline Mann
I love Multipliers.

Pete Mockaitis
And a shout out to Liz Wiseman, a former guest on the show. And a favorite tool, something you use to be awesome at your job?

Madeline Mann
I use a lot of Evernote. My entire business is really based on me putting out value into the world, and value can come in inspiration of client conversations, of podcast interviews.

And so, to have somewhere easily accessible that I’m writing down all of my ideas, keeping them organized, cultivating them over time. So, just, you know, it’s a very simple tool, but that one’s been really helpful for me to just track all of these thoughts that are bubbling in my head.

Pete Mockaitis
And a favorite habit?

Madeline Mann
I always use a notebook. I am constantly writing in my notebook and it’s filled with to-do lists. And I probably go through a notebook in, like, a couple weeks. And something about having my to-do lists written down, and even just, like, often in conversations, I’ll write down notes.

Writing down notes is part of one of the secrets to, I feel, like, my success, with my being organized. But to have things just, like, written here, keeping my priorities very clear for the day. Checking them off is so gratifying. That is my favorite habit.

Pete Mockaitis

And is there a key nugget you share that really seems to resonate with folks, they quote it back to you often?

Madeline Mann
“Your resume is a sales page, not a Wikipedia page.”

Pete Mockaitis
I like it. And if folks want to learn more or get in touch, where would you point them?

Madeline Mann
I would say, find me at MadelineMann.com. You can find me there. You can also find me all across different social media channels, YouTube, “Self-Made Millennial,” LinkedIn, all of that. But, yes, MadelineMann.com as a core hub.

Pete Mockaitis

And do you have a final challenge or call to action for folks looking to be awesome at their jobs?

Madeline Mann

“What’s the best that could happen?” Okay. I want you to think of that every time you go out of your comfort zone, where it’s comfortable, it’s crowded. So, get uncomfortable in the job search. And every time you do something that feels a little funky, reach out to someone new, just think, “What’s the best that can happen?”

Pete Mockaitis

All right. Madeline, fabulous. Thank you.

Madeline Mann
Thank you.

1063: Getting Meetings with Unreachable People with Stu Heinecke

By Podcasts No Comments

Stu Heinecke shares fun and unconventional methods to reach VIPs.

You’ll Learn

  1. The secret behind Stu’s 100% response rate
  2. The master key to grabbing people’s attention
  3. What AI can and can’t do for your outreach

About Stu

Stu Heinecke is a Wall Street Journal cartoonist, Hall of Fame-nominated marketer and author. Heinecke discovered the magic of “Contact Marketing” early in his career, when he launched a Contact Campaign to just two dozen Vice Presidents and Directors of Circulation at the big Manhattan-based magazine publishers. That tiny $100 investment resulted in a 100% response rate, launched his enterprise and brought in millions of dollars worth of business.

Heinecke is the host and author of the How To Get A Meeting with Anyone podcast and blog, and founder and president of Contact, a Contact Marketing agency, and cofounder of Cartoonists.org, a coalition of famed cartoonists dedicated to raising funds for charity, while raising the profile of the cartooning art form. He lives on an island in the pristine Pacific Northwest with his wife, Charlotte, and their dog, Bo.

Resources Mentioned

Thank you, Sponsors!

Pete Mockaitis
Stu, welcome back!

Stu Heinecke
I am so glad to be back. I don’t know where I was, but I’m glad to be back.

Pete Mockaitis

Well, we’re going to find out, you know, what both of us have been up to in six years.

Stu Heinecke
We will.

Pete Mockaitis
I had so much fun chatting with you last time about “How to Get a Meeting with Anyone,” and you’ve got an updated edition coming out here. And so, I think it’s worth talking about this at least every six years, so let’s do it.

Stu Heinecke
It’s actually more like nine years.

Pete Mockaitis
Was it, really?

Stu Heinecke
Since it came out, that’s why there’s an Updated Edition.

Pete Mockaitis
Oh, six years since we talked, nine years since the update.

Stu Heinecke
Yeah.

Pete Mockaitis
Yeah. Okay. Well, so for those of us who weren’t with us in our last conversation, can you refresh us to your origin story and how you became a guru of getting meetings with anyone?

Stu Heinecke
Well, early in my career, I wanted to create direct mail for magazine publishers, and I ended up producing this little campaign to reach out to the VPs of circulation and consumer marketing at the publishers like Time Inc. and Conde Nast, and so forth. And I wanted to break through to that industry. And what it meant was I just needed to reach about two dozen people. That’s all it was. And that covered the entire publishing industry.

And so, I put together a campaign. It referenced a couple of test campaigns that I’d just done, just completed for Rolling Stone and Bon Appétit. And both of those beat their controls, meaning both of those set new records for response, like all-time records. And so, okay, well, that was my entree to put this campaign out.

Pete Mockaitis
And if I may, with beating the controls, just so we can visualize, when you say campaign, what are we talking about here?

Stu Heinecke
We’re talking about a direct mail campaign to send through the mail, to ask people to subscribe to the magazines. But the kicker was I was using cartoons with personalization, and no one was doing that, so I knew that that was a winning combination because I knew that readership surveys were showing that cartoons were almost always the best read and remembered parts of magazines or newspapers. They were going to show up and people were going to pay attention to them. And they did.

Pete Mockaitis
So, it was like, “Hey, Pete, I’m in a cartoon.” It’s like, “Whoa, I’m in cartoon.”

Stu Heinecke
Yeah, kind of. Yeah, it’s just they’re talking. One of the characters is talking about you or mentioning you.”

Pete Mockaitis

Yeah, I like it.

Stu Heinecke
And you come out on top in the humor, generally, yeah. So, I created those two campaigns, and then I thought, “Okay, that’s my entree to reach out to the rest of the publishing industry.” And as I mentioned, I put together a little campaign, called it a contact campaign.

And it consisted of a little 8×10 print of a cartoon, each one’s personalized to each recipient. And then a note saying, “This is the device I just used to beat the controls for Rolling Stone and Bon Appetit, and I think we should put these to the test for your titles.”

Pete Mockaitis
Bam!

Stu Heinecke
Now, I don’t know if you remember the story, because I guess I might quiz you there. What do you think I got for a response rate to that?

Pete Mockaitis
If we’re thinking about the same story, I deliberately didn’t read the whole transcript to keep it a little fresh.

Stu Heinecke
Good. Good.

Pete Mockaitis
I believe you told me your response rate was over 100%. I said, “Stu, how is that even possible?” And you said, “Some of them referred me extra work on top of it.”

Stu Heinecke
Okay. Well, it was 100% but we’re mixing other campaigns that have done that. But it was 100%. All of them, first of all, just responded. All of them then agreed to meet, so 100% meeting rate. And then all of them became clients, 100% conversion rate. And what it did was it took me from being an unknown. I was just 24, I think, 23 or 24. It took me from being an unknown to suddenly being one of the top creatives in that market almost overnight from a campaign that went to 24 people and cost me about a hundred bucks. So, that was my first time using contact marketing. Yeah, and what an eye-opener that was.

Pete Mockaitis
Yeah, it’s so beautiful and it’s winning on so many levels. And I guess you’ve had some time to think about how and why did this work. But it seems of, well, one, that your actual offer at root is awesome in terms of, “Hey, I can make you more money for your business. And, oh, by the way, you know, some of your peers that you really respect and value in the industry, they have seen it happen.” So, it’s like that core offer and message, in and of itself, is phenomenal.

If we’re offering them a home warranty renewal, you know, we wouldn’t see that no matter how amazing your cartoon was. And then next up, you straight up got their attention with a novel, physical medium packaging, right? Like, “Huh, what’s this?”

Stu Heinecke
Yeah. And I thought, “Well, gee, aren’t I cool? I can use cartoons and I can reach almost anyone.” I’m like, “Who could I reach?” And I thought, “You know, I’ve got to try this. How far can I go with this?” I’m kind of a mischievous person. So, I started reaching out to presidents and prime ministers and celebrities and lots of C-level executives and top decision-makers, and I was getting through.

I can’t say I got through to all of them, but I’ve gotten through to several presidents, a prime minister, or a number of celebrities. You know, it’s really interesting because I’ve been thinking all along, “Wow, I’m able to put myself in contact with people I should never be able to reach.”

And then I thought, “Why should you never be able to reach them? Why should anybody not be able to reach whoever it is that they want to reach?” I mean, that’s kind of the whole premise behind the book.

Pete Mockaitis
Well, so I think that this is a big idea and it’s exciting. Can you give us some more stories of this in action so we can marinate on it a little bit, and say, “Hmm, how might I apply this in my world and my meeting that I want to get?”

Stu Heinecke
Here’s one really interesting. I can’t say the name of the company, but there was this sales rep who was calling. If you’ve seen the movie “Forrest Gump,” then you’ll understand my reference to a certain fruit company. Otherwise, you won’t.

But he was calling on the fruit company’s engineering department, and they loved his software solution, they said, “But we don’t control budget, so you’re going to have to talk to purchasing.” So, he thought, “Oh, man, great. This is great. I’ve got a sale.” But purchasing wouldn’t talk to him. And so, he thought, “Oh, what am I going to do? Well, I know, I’ll go around him. I’ll go around them to the CEO of this fruit company,” who happened to be at the time the most famous CEO in the world.

He was not going to be easy to reach. And the sales rep discovered that because he was sending faxes and letters and leaving messages and doing anything he could think of and nothing was happening. So, one day, this plywood box shows up at the front counter with air holes drilled into it and a handwritten note. And the note was addressed to the CEO.

And the rep said, “I’ve been calling on your engineering department. They love my solution. They told me to talk to purchasing. They won’t talk to me. I’ve been trying everything I can think of, otherwise than to reach you and nothing has worked. So, this is my final attempt. So, if you would, open the box carefully. And inside the box is a pigeon. And on the pigeon’s leg is a little capsule with a slip of paper inside.”

“So, if you’ll take that slip of paper out, write the name of your favorite restaurant, a date and a time, put it back in the capsule and release the pigeon, I’ll meet you there. And I wouldn’t be telling the story if the pigeon didn’t come back, right?” So, the pigeon came back. There was a name of a restaurant, a date, the time, and they got together. They met and he walked out of that with a $250,000 deal.

Pete Mockaitis
I love that so much because, okay, it’s clever, it’s fun, it’s novel, and I’m learning something that the pigeon stuff still works today, huh, in terms of, like, pigeons are capable of returning to their original destination. Because I imagine that if I were the CEO, pardon me, I’ll give him respect, some props, like, “Okay, that’s very cool. That’s very clever. That’s interesting. You’re committed. You’re creative. All right, cool, cool.” But, I’m also curious, like, “Hmm, does this pigeon thing even work? Let’s take a crack at it.”

Stu Heinecke
Yeah, you got to try it.

Pete Mockaitis
So, I’m motivated there, too.

Stu Heinecke
A lot of these stories, they really contain a huge measure of audacity. So, I mean, really taking a risk, it’s just way out of left field. It’s just crazy. So, I think one of the things that people are responding to is, if you do something that gives them a story to tell, then they love it. Of course, they get engaged with it, but they love it because they want to tell a story. And there are lots of these where there’s a story and you’re just, “Oh, my God, that’s just astonishing.”

Pete Mockaitis
I think that’s a great takeaway in terms of it gives them a story to share, it’s valuable in and of its own right, and it just takes so much effort, you can’t help but respect it in terms of, because it takes zero effort to have a cold email, automated cold email. Some can be very thoughtful and well researched, but you can’t mass blast pigeons.

Stu Heinecke
No. And, you know, when you’re on LinkedIn and you get a message, a request for a connection, and it says, “Hey…” because the pitches, they’re always generic. So, it’s just, “Hey, I read your profile, and I know a lot of people just like you.” I’m thinking you’ve missed the mark. Don’t say that to someone because you don’t know anything about me.

Pete Mockaitis
“I’m a unique person.”

Stu Heinecke
I wouldn’t be able to look at my profile and know much about me. So, how are you? Obviously, you’re spraying this out to, who knows, hundreds, thousands of people. I’m not going to waste my time. So, yeah, the pigeon, but audacity, I don’t think you can do that at a great quantity level.

Pete Mockaitis
Oh, sure.

Stu Heinecke
I mean, you just got to be one-on-one. And, really, ultimately, the goal we’re seeking is we want people to receive this, Dale Dupree calls it an experience. I think that’s a good way of describing it, but receive this thing that you’ve sent or done and just say, “Wow, who is this?” Like, going from, “Who is this?” to, “My God, who is this? I got to meet this person. This is hilarious.”

Pete Mockaitis

Yes.

Stu Heinecke

So, if you do that, then if you’ve opened the conversation together, or really the relationship together in that way, then you’ve given them a story.

Pete Mockaitis
I dig it. I dig it. Let’s hear more stories.

Stu Heinecke
All right. There’s one that involves two singers. So, Johnny Cash, Kris Kristofferson.

Pete Mockaitis
Yeah. Well, I’m talking to you from Hendersonville, Tennessee, so Johnny Cash is…

Stu Heinecke
Oh, my God, then you know all about him. Well, so Kris, much younger man than Johnny, Johnny was one of his heroes, Kris was in the army stationed in Germany, flying helicopters, and he was trying to figure out what is the next steps were in his life. And he thought, “Well, I know, I want to become a singer-songwriter. I want to move to Nashville. And you know what? I want to meet Johnny Cash and I want to collaborate with him. I want to be his best friend.” Those were his goals.

So, he finished his tour of duty in Germany and moved to Nashville. And one of his friends knew that he wanted to meet Johnny Cash. So, he had a backstage pass. Got him in. There was Johnny. He was just about to go on. And he said, “Hey, Johnny, I just wanted to introduce a friend of mine. This is Kris.”

And Johnny turns and looks and he goes, “Hey, how you doing?” And then turns away because he’s going on stage. That was it. There was no impression whatsoever. Well, then Kris thought, “Okay, then I’ll get a job at the studio where Johnny records,” Columbia Studio in Nashville, I believe.

So, the only job they had was a janitor. And Kris was a Rhodes scholar. This was a real sacrifice to do this. But, anyway, he took the job as a janitor. They were all told, by the way, if you slip a demo tape to Johnny, you’re fired. So, he slipped them to June instead, his wife. It still didn’t work. So, one day, he thought, “God, I’ve got to do something. I got to make something happen here.”

So, one day, he was still flying helicopters as well. So, he was out on a flight, I don’t know what he was doing, going to an oil rig or something, but finishing up, and he thought, “I know what I’m going to. I have my demo tape. I’m going to stop by.” And he said that’s what he did. He flew over, and he landed on Johnny’s front lawn.

Pete Mockaitis
Oh, nice.

Stu Heinecke
And handed off a demo tape that way. Now, Johnny and Kris remember the story differently, because Johnny said, “Yeah, so then here’s Kris. I’ve known him for a couple of years from the studio. But here he was, he comes over, lands a helicopter, steps out from the helicopter with a beer in one hand and a demo tape in the other.” And Kris was always saying, “I can’t fly a helicopter. I need both hands. There’s no way I was flying with a beer.”

But what was happening was Johnny was already full force. He was just into that story. I mean, I think we know him. They became, from that point on, they became collaborators. Kris wrote a lot of songs, and Johnny recorded a lot of those, introduced to him to a lot, his career just exploded from that one helicopter flight, but he landed a helicopter on his front lawn to get his attention.

And until he did that, until he showed, I don’t know, kind of the audacity, till he showed the audacity to do that, I don’t think you would even get on Johnny’s radar. He wasn’t.

Pete Mockaitis
So, Stu, I’m thinking, “Can I even legally charter a helicopter flight to land in someone’s yard? Was there like a flight plans or FAA things that are going to stop me?”

Stu Heinecke
I don’t know. You know, I’m amazed he wasn’t arrested for it. I don’t know. I never heard anything about that.

Pete Mockaitis
Well, you said they’re taking a risk. I was like, “Oh, you know, you’re risking time and money and embarrassment, but you might also be risking law enforcement action in some contexts.”

Stu Heinecke
You might go to jail. You might lose your license. All kinds of stuff.

Pete Mockaitis
Well, so I like this. I want more reps of the stories because I think it starts to spark other ideas. Let’s hear the sword story.

Stu Heinecke
Oh, yeah. Well, that is, so Dan Waldschmidt is the man behind that story. And Dan, he’s a blogger, he’s one of the top sales bloggers, and an author. And his branding is around, well, it is edgy conversation, so sort of knife’s edge, ultra competitiveness. Dan runs, he trains a lot, and he runs 100-mile races and he wins these things. He’s in great shape. He’s an amazing competitor.

And so, he brings all of that to bear in his sort of, let’s say, personal branding. But what he really is, he’s a turnaround specialist. And so, he shared with me his process for reaching the CEOs of companies that are in trouble. And what he does is he scans the business news every day for stories of missed earnings estimates. And when he finds one, he has a sword made by the prop maker who made the sword for the movie “Gladiator.”

But they’re great swords. They’re not sharpened. Thankfully, that’s a great feature if you’re going to send someone something like that. The blade has an inscription, “If you’re not all in, you’re not in at all,” and then it has the CEO’s name engraved on it as well. And it comes in a beautiful wooden box, felt line, with a handwritten note. And handwritten notes tend to show up a lot in these. And I think one of the reasons that that’s also relevant now is that that’s not something AI does.

So, the note says something to the effect that “A business is war. I noticed you lost a battle recently. I just wanted to let you know, if you ever need a few extra hands in battle, we’ve got your back.” And what he’s saying is, “We’ll stand side by side with you and go to battle with you, for you, to win this battle.”

And so, he is getting 100% response rate to that so far. I want to say it costs him about $1,000 every time he puts one of those out. And by 100% response rate, I mean that all of those CEOs will take his call. All of them will talk to him. Not all of them do business with him, but that’s the next step. When he does business with them, and when he has an assignment, a turnaround assignment, it’s worth, generally, a million dollars and up. So, if you spend $1,000 on the sword, it’s worth it.

Pete Mockaitis
That’s cool. That’s cool. Well, so let’s say we’ve got a job seeker who’s thinking, “Boy, you know what, my dream would just be to work for…” fill in the blank, “Oh, it’d be the coolest thing ever if I could work for Netflix…” or, “…for Pete Mockaitis…” or, “…the How to be Awesome at Your Job podcast.”

Stu Heinecke

Absolutely.

Pete Mockaitis
I’ll just put it on the same level, if I may, yeah. And so, if someone has that idea, but was like, “But I can’t get their attention, there are these AI resume screeners. I apply and it goes nowhere. Stu, how do I use this?”

And so, it seems like a sword or a carrier pigeon or a helicopter, it’s interesting because there are economic considerations in terms of, if we don’t have a million-dollar size of prize, but rather we might see like a $20,000 raise, is the size of the prize, you know, who knows what percent of success we’re going to get.

So, I’d say, let’s just say, I’ll challenge you a little bit, under 200 bucks total cash budget per contact. I’m trying to get my dream job at Netflix, or with Pete Mockaitis, how might I play this game?

Stu Heinecke
One of the techniques that I think is really interesting is, I call it deep personalization in “Get the Meetings,” the later book after “How to Get a Meeting with Anyone.”

But it’s doing a profile scrape. And now with AI, my God, we can get some really crazy-level profile scrapes because you can find out a lot about who they are, what they like to do, what they’re talking about. AI will just go scrape it for you, and it’s amazing, really amazing.

So, when you find out something about someone, that they love maybe Korean War fighters, and they love flying in jets. Well, actually, you said under 200. You could show them the jet. I don’t think you could get them a ride for two. I don’t know if you can get it for a 200.

But certainly, you can come up with a gift that reflects that, and it doesn’t have to be an expensive gift. I guess it just depends. And it probably shouldn’t be because gifting is often restricted by companies. They can’t accept a gift over $20.

So, I don’t know, it might be, let’s say, a rare book or an old book about MiGs or something like that. Go to eBay and search around and find something on that subject and send it to them. And it comes across as a very thoughtful gift. Just tell them, “I was doing research.” This is actually the basis of something called a wow mailer.

But just say in the note that, “I was doing research because I wanted to meet you. And I discovered that you were really, really interested in MiGs, MiG fighters,” let’s stick with that theme here. “And I thought you’d enjoy this book that I found on MiGs. And I hope it will actually, perhaps it will earn me the opportunity to speak with you.” So, that’s a nice way to do it.

Well, you know I’m a cartoonist as well. I’m one of the Wall Street Journal cartoonists. And so, I would probably send them a card or maybe a larger piece, but a cartoon about themselves. Oh, especially if it also then backed into the research, the scrapes. So, suddenly I know that they’re interested in MiGs, then I’ll work that into the cartoon. So, that might be a way.

But I really think just doing something with a profile scrape and discovering something about them that they really, really treasure in life, and then fashion a gift around it. It’d be a great way to do it. But here’s another one. A lot of people have sent their resumes, or dropped their resumes off, taped to a donut box, or a box full of donuts. I mean, that’s kind of like a Trojan horse, I think.

And then my friend, Dale Dupree, also does something interesting. He has empty donut boxes delivered. I mean, you can see sort of the detritus from the donuts that were in there, but there’s a note inside saying, in his case, he was saying, “I was waiting to meet you, or to do our deal, but it took so long. I ended up eating all the donuts,” and then there’s a donut card inside and it’s something like that. Just something that gives someone, as I’ve said, an experience or a story to tell.

Pete Mockaitis
Yeah, I remember, I shared the story with you last time we spoke. There was a coaching client I had, he wanted to work at McKinsey and Company, you know, get in a competitive consulting organization. He was in a Target recruiting school. On his own birthday, he sent birthday cake to the office, and said, “All I want for my birthday is an interview with McKinsey.”

Stu Heinecke
Oh, yeah.

Pete Mockaitis
And it worked out. It worked out.

Stu Heinecke
Look at that.

Pete Mockaitis
So, yeah, so sweet treats, combined with resumes and/or a request.

So, AI is really cool for scraping and getting the details on what they might be into. I’m curious, fundamental question, how do I just get the mailing address?

Stu Heinecke
Well, yeah, so a little bit. So, you don’t have to send something physical. That also should be said. But you have to be careful about sending things to their home address. And I know people are working from home, so that’s their address.

I would suggest something different, though. You could find their address, their home address, and I think if you sent them something, and they don’t know you and they haven’t given permission, or just said, “Yeah, please send it. That sounds interesting,” you’re going to come off like a stalker. So,

Call ahead and find out, “I’m sending something to you,” or, “I’m sending something to your boss,” if they have assistants, “And I just want to know, if I send it to the office, is that the best place to send it?” And then they’ll say, “Yes, it’ll get to them,” or, “No, why don’t you send it to their home address?” and then they’ll give the address.

I think you want to have some kind of clearance from it, so that if you send something to someone at their home, and they’re saying, “How did you get my address?” “Well, I got it from your assistant. And they said, send it to you there.” “Oh, okay.” It’s diffused. But I do think if you’re sending it to someone’s home address, it can get creepy really quickly. So, you’ve got to be careful.

But AI is giving us all kinds of options, not only for finding addresses, but also, of course, picking up on buyer intent signals and trigger events.

So, if you know your ideal customer profile, you can find people who are not only fitting that profile, but also fitting in terms of timing based on trigger events and interest, expressed interest because that’s based on their search patterns. So, if they’re suddenly searching for what you sell, man, that’s a good time to be talking to them.

Pete Mockaitis
Now, is this just like standard Google Ads, or is there some software magic you like under the hood?

Stu Heinecke
Well, there are several platforms. You know, Seamless and Zoominfo and Apollo.io and so on. They are all doing that. They all have, now, buyer intent signals built into it. I think the first platform that did it was 6sense. One thing I don’t like from some of the platforms after that is, then, they’re set up to send email sequences.

And I think email sequences are, I guess, I hesitate to call them dead, but we see them, we know what they look like. And if you’re getting email after email, and each email is a page-long copy, it has page-long copy, you’re not going to read that.

And, also, that it has the slogan at the bottom, “This was sent to you by such-and-such. If you want to opt out…” or rather unsubscribe, do this with all those links at the bottom of those broadcast emails. All of that is just a cue to the person on the other end, “This is not personal.” They’ve just put you into a mill and they’re taking up your time with automation.

Pete Mockaitis
Yeah, it’s funny how I’ve had a number of businesses, maybe this is even your experience appearing on podcasts. It’s, like, some of the emails are from the podcaster, and those are real, and you may wish to reply to them. And others are automations from the calendar software. And I would hope that you would go ahead and read the guest prep materials, but you know that those are not real.

So, in a world where we have too many emails, and unless you’re just absolutely desperately in need of the thing that is being mentioned, yeah, that’s one of our top filters, I think. It’s like, “Not a real person. Not actually for me personally.”

Stu Heinecke
If it comes across that way, you just dump it. And so, that’s what I was saying at the outset. Our mission is to create human-to-human connections. AI is magical, I think. It’s miraculous. But when we’re talking about, then, getting meetings with people and making connections with people, well, that’s what we’re doing, human-to-human connections. It’s not machine-to-human connections.

And as soon as the human gets any sort of inkling that that’s what’s happening, then you are persona non grata. You’re not going to get through. You will never get through. You’ll be blocked.

Pete Mockaitis
Well, speaking of not getting through and getting blocked, I guess, what’s so exciting about your book and your concept, “How to Get a Meeting with Anyone,” and then just like the zone of creativity is like, “Oh, if I discover a really cool personalized thing, then that’ll do the trick.” But I think what’s hard here is, “I need to have the permission for the home address.” So, it feels like you can get blocked there pretty easily.

Stu Heinecke
Yeah, I always advocate calling the assistant. If you’re going to someone at the level that has an assistant, but calling ahead and just saying, “Hi, my name is such and such. I’m calling because I’m sending a print of a cartoon by one of the New Yorker or Wall Street Journal cartoonists, and it’s about your boss.” Well, I call that a VIP statement in the book. That is a statement that causes the person on the other end of the line to say, “Oh, whoa, okay. Well, cool. Oh, I got to listen to this.”

So, then there’s a script that goes with it, “So, yeah, it is about your boss. I’d love to send you an email just so I can confirm the details, and I’ll give you my contact information. And then as soon as I have the FedEx tracking number, I will send that to you as well.” So, it’s actually still in production when you do that, or it could be pre-production. So, if they say no, then you don’t send them one. But I think it makes a lot of sense to call ahead and to start.

Pete Mockaitis
Oh, I certainly do. I guess, if you’re addressing what I was worried about, it’s like, “Well, they might just shut you down now.” It’s like, “We don’t know you. We don’t want your stuff.”

Stu Heinecke
Maybe. But I think that the line, that VIP statement helps a lot. You know, I’m in the middle of writing a new book, and I wanted to reach Bjorn Ulvaeus from ABBA. Well, ABBA is still one of the biggest bands in the world, and it’s not going to be easy to reach him. And so, I used one of my new devices. It’s a FedEx piece, a really cool piece. And I have to reach his publicist, and I wasn’t even sure I was going to reach her, but I did reach her just yesterday.

So, there’s the rest of the context and the whole gag. You can reach out to just about anybody. And when you do, magic can happen. And it’s pretty amazing. So, certainly, magic can happen in your job search as well.

Pete Mockaitis
Stu, tell me, if someone’s listening and they think, “I could use AI to make a cartoon,” what do you say to them?

Stu Heinecke
I just put the finger across the throat. Here’s the thing. Here’s the deal. And, actually, it’s a really interesting question because, as things become more automated and artificial through AI, I think that people are going to clamor for things that are uniquely human, things that only humans can do. And I would say cartoons are one of those.

So, I’ve watched it very carefully. I’m on a few of the text-to-image platforms, and I’ve prompted, every once in a while, to come up with just a…it’s a really tough thing to do to come up with a funny, something that’s funny. And AI is getting better at that. But then also the cartoon drawings so far, they’re really, I mean, they don’t look like…there’s this rawness to a Roz Chast cartoon, or I don’t know, Peter Steiner, any of them. There’s a rawness to it that is utterly human.

And when you ask an AI to produce a cartoon, well, first of all, it’s generally, it’s just a drawing. Yeah, it’s just a drawing or whatever it is. It’s just an image. And it’s more like a Saturday…how do I put it? Almost like a Saturday morning, 3D Saturday morning kiddies cartoon kind of thing. It’s not sophisticated. It’s not something you’d look at and go, “Oh, gosh, what is this? This looks hilarious.” It just looks like characters on a TV show, 3D animation TV show.

So, there’s still, so far, it’s not something that AI can do. It should be good enough that the person on the other end says, “Wow, you actually sat down and wrote this to me. Who is this?”

Pete Mockaitis
Yeah. All right. Well, Stu, tell me, anything else you want to mention before we hear about your favorite things?

Stu Heinecke
Well, I guess I should hold up the book because I just got a copy of it. There it is, “How to Get a Meeting with Anyone,” the new edition. It’s purple, this time. But it has new chapters dealing with those things that we’ve just talked about, AI, and how AI, work from home, and just the dearth of digital spam everywhere, every channel is changing the way we get meetings.

But still, it’s not changing them because, on the other hand, we’re still using things that are audacious and clever, and they open a conversation with someone in a pretty magical way. And it only happens when it’s human to human.

So, I would advise you, if I was in the middle of a job search, I would be using this stuff for sure because I wouldn’t want to rely on the AI algorithms to pick my resume out of all, I don’t know, the thousands. I wouldn’t want to even rest my fate in the hands of HR. I wouldn’t. I would feel like they don’t even understand what I’m talking about.

And so, I would be reaching out to the CEO, and letting them know that I’m interested in working with them. I mean, not even apply. Maybe just reach out to CEOs anyway. I think CEOs, you know, if you impress them, then their job is to build a team. And so, if you impress them enough, I think you end up in a situation where they’re saying, “God, we need someone like this on our team.” And that will happen.

Pete Mockaitis
Lovely. Well, now can you share a favorite quote, something you find inspiring?

Stu Heinecke
What comes to mind is I did another book, I wrote another book called “How to Grow Your Business Like a Weed” that came after, and I got some great, great quotes from all sorts of sources. But my favorite quote out of there is, “Give a weed an inch and it’ll take a yard.” So, I love that one. And I guess maybe Winston Churchill’s, “If you’re going through hell, keep going.”

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. And a favorite book?

Stu Heinecke

I like some of the sales books by Jeb Blount and Mark Hunter. You’ve probably had them on.

Pete Mockaitis
You know, could make the scheduling work. I’d love to get Jeb on.

Stu Heinecke
Oh, yeah, he’s great. He’s great. He writes a lot of great, great books. He’s prolific. And he and Anthony Iannarino teamed up to write a book about AI and sales. I think that’s really interesting. So, anything by Jeb Blount, anything by Mark Hunter, anything by Victor Antonio, anything by Anthony Iannarino, lots of great, great stuff coming out.

Pete Mockaitis

Okay. And a favorite habit?

Stu Heinecke
I’m working out like a fiend. The real habit, though, is going in four or five times a week and working out an hour and half to two hours, and it does pay dividends. It’s amazing.

Pete Mockaitis

And is there a key nugget you share that really seems to resonate with folks, you hear them quoting it back you often?

Stu Heinecke

“If you can’t get meetings, you can’t sell.”

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. And if folks want to learn more again or get in touch, where would you point them?

Stu Heinecke
You can mention that you saw or heard me on your podcast. Let’s just go to LinkedIn and connect with me there. Or you can go to StuHeinecke.com, my name is S-T-U H-E-I-N-E-C-K-E.com, and that’s my author site. And you’ll find offers and all sorts of interesting things there.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. And do you have a final challenge or call to action for folks looking to be awesome at their jobs?

Stu Heinecke
If you’re looking for a job, man, if you’re going through the usual channels, the channels that everyone else is going, if you’re using best practices, the things that everyone else is doing, keep in mind you’re not standing out. That’s not the way you stand out. You heard stories about Kris Kristofferson landing a helicopter on Johnny Cash’s front lawn, you’ve heard stories of dropping pigeons off, and so on. That’s how you stand out. You got to take risks.

Pete Mockaitis
All right. Stu, thank you.

Stu Heinecke
You’re very welcome. Thank you for having me on.

928: The Introvert’s Powerful Approach to Networking with Matthew Pollard

By Podcasts One Comment

 

 

Matthew Pollard shares networking wisdom that anyone, particularly introverts, can use for great benefit.

You’ll Learn:

  1. The best way to answer “What do you do?”
  2. The two relationships that will transform your network
  3. The simple trick to get people interested in your expertise 

About Matthew

Matthew Pollard, known as “The Rapid Growth Guy,” works with businesses around the world, from startups to Fortune 500 companies like Microsoft and Capital One. Responsible for launching five zero-to-million-dollar businesses, he also founded Austin’s Small Business Festival, which is now a nationwide event. A native of Australia, he splits his time between North Carolina and Texas.

Resources Mentioned

Pete Mockaitis
Matthew, welcome.

Matthew Pollard
Mate, I’m ecstatic to be here. Thanks for having me on.

Pete Mockaitis
Oh, thank you. I want to know, you’re the rapid growth guy, so why are we writing a book called The Introvert’s Edge to Networking?

Matthew Pollard
It’s funny. People would assume that rapid growth, sales success, networking success, is kind of an oxymoron with the concept of introversion. And while a lot of people think that, it’s totally not true. Let’s confront the stigma head on for a second. Most people think that introverts are terrible at small talk, yet David Letterman and Oprah Winfrey are introverts, so that makes no sense.

And then, “Oh, yeah, but we definitely can’t sell.” Well, Zig Ziglar, the most well-known sales trainer on the planet, who’s no longer with us, but him and his son, Tom Ziglar, are very introverted. And then you’ve got, “Oh, okay, if we can sell and we can do small talk, networking is the thing we definitely can’t do.” Well, that’s also not true. Ivan Misner, the founder of BNI, the world’s largest networking group, is an introvert as well.

So, really, I’m known as the rapid growth guy because I’ve been responsible for five multimillion-dollar success stories, and I help organizations, predominantly introverted small business-based, small business owners, obtain rapid growth in their business because I find them, they get stuck in this endless hamster wheel of struggling to find interested people, trying to set themselves apart, trying to make the sale, and always fighting on price, but also corporate executives. They have no idea how to sell their value.

And I find that the same methodology applies for people to create rapid growth in their careers as well. So, that’s how I’ve got the name but I spend my life trying to help introverts realize they’re not second-class citizens. Their path to success is just different to that of an extrovert.

Pete Mockaitis
Beautiful. All right. Well, could you perhaps share a tale that lays it out in terms of what’s at stake for introverts, and whether they are networking well or not so well?

Matthew Pollard
Well, I think for a lot of people, there’s that old adage that, “If people don’t know your value, then it doesn’t matter how much you know. You’re never going to succeed in your career.” So, your network is directly related to your net worth. I think that’s changing a lot in the digital forum, but the truth is that I’m always pushing people to learn how to articulate their value in the networking room, whether they’re a career professional, whether they’re an executive, whether they’re just getting started in a career right through, and more especially for small business owners.

Because if you can’t articulate your value, and somebody’s politely listening to you in a room for two, two and a half minutes, you just got no chance online because people, then, give you fractions of a second. And I’ve seen people that we allow, or help get their messaging right in a networking room that have then gone on headhunted and get six figure increases in salary just because they’re getting their message correct. But without that in-the-room validation, it doesn’t work.

Pete Mockaitis
Well, let’s double click on that for a moment. Six figure increases in salary, that’s lovely. So, if someone’s going from 125,000 to 225,000, for example, near doubling, all based upon effectively having a good two-minute exchange with somebody?

Matthew Pollard
This ideology actually started in the small business space. And what was funny is I actually had a lady that read my book, she reached out to me, and she was a small business owner at the time, and she said she was trying to get a corporate job. And I actually responded with, “You know, that’s not what I do.”

And she got upset with me, and she literally said, “Look, I know your ideology will work for corporations, and because there aren’t many authors in the introverted space, I just believe that you can help me.” And she said, “Really, I’m just trying to get one customer, one corporation to hire me.” I mean, “That’s kind of true but I can’t give you my online program. We have to work one-on-one. I’m willing to give it a shot if you’re up for it.”

And what was really interesting is we applied the methodology. And what I always focus on is you need to know the niche that you’re going after. And so, for her, what we’ve helped her realize was her real love was education technology. So, we got her to focus on education technology, we created a message for her, and she actually got a job that paid 180,000.

But the one specifically I was talking about was another gentleman that we worked with around the same time, and he actually was going to start his own business, and then he actually got hit by hurricane Katrina out in Texas. And I was like, “Mate, you’ve got scarcity in your life and uncertainty everywhere. You shouldn’t be starting your own business now.” He said, “But I want to start my own business. I don’t want to work.”

He was working for a large bank, and he said, “I’m traveling 250 days a year, and, on top of that, I’ve got to deal with all the stuff back home, and I feel like I’m always dealing with the same problem over and over, and I want to deal with lots of different types of clients.” And I said, “I don’t think you want to go and start your own business. I think that what you really want to do is work with an organization that has lots of business units. Then you can have the safety and security of an employment job but you can still work in lots of different business units and apply your ideology. But let’s understand what your ideology is.”

And what we realized is what he loved to do was create customer-centric moments that created organizational growth, so create that special contact moment that allowed that person that had that special contact to, then, share the praise with other people that created referrals and become more stickier customer and buy more stuff. So, I said, “What I believe you specialize in is creating these customer-centric moments which, then, creates a growth velocity for the organization that you work with, but you don’t need to work in your own business to do that. You can do that in a corporation. What we need to do is call you something like,” and I came up with the term the velocity architect.

And I said, “Call yourself the velocity architect, don’t call yourself a marketer, because when you say you’re a marketer, they put you in a box with everybody else. And while that may be what you need to do to get your first job, the people that go from middle to top-level management, they need to separate themselves. They’ve got to have something unique.”

So, we called him the velocity architect. We created the three major problems that most organizations have where they struggle to create customer velocity because they don’t create these customer-centric moments. And following up, he went from an interview with an energy company that had multiple business units, and it was a six-figure job but it was low six figures. I think it was about a $150,000-$190,000 job. And when he went for the interview, he introduced himself as the velocity architect, he talked about these customer-centric engagements, and he learned how to tell stories.

Because a lot of people try to educate on their value, and stories work far better. But once he did that, the person that he was doing the interview with said, “Look, you’re overqualified for this job but my CEO needs to meet you.” And they actually created a job for him that actually paid. It was over 100,000, it was in the 200s, more than the job he was applying for.

Because what you’ve got to understand in today’s world, people are looking, and I’m not talking about low-level jobs. I’m talking about medium to high-level jobs. They are looking for people that have ideologies that give their organizations value, and they’ll create jobs for you. They’ll headhunt people that have unique points of view. And in today’s digital world, if you can learn how to articulate that clearly and concisely in a networking room, you can leverage that online, you’ll find yourself getting headhunted. You’ll be able to leverage that message online and have people all over the world trying to recruit you.

Pete Mockaitis
Matthew, this is an intriguing thesis. You’ve got some juicy case studies and examples. Do you have any other compelling evidence that suggests that, in fact, this unique point of view that you have about unique points of view is dead-on true?

Matthew Pollard
The truth is that when you’re looking to go to a networking room, and, if you’re a small business owner listening to this, you should never be going to a networking room to try and find clients. I know you think that that’s what you need but, for me, finding another client is the wrong direction to go.

My belief is that finding, what I would call, momentum partners and champion relationships are where the power is and for career people listening that have got jobs, this is just as powerful for you because if you go to a networking room, and you’re looking for that next person that’s going to hire you, well, if you’re not looking for a job right now, it’s going to convince you that don’t need to be networking.

But then, on top of that, the biggest relationships that I have found useful in everything that you do, firstly, momentum partners, people that believe in what you do, and are willing to talk to other people about it, and you believe in what they do. And because of that, this ideology works much more effectively because if I said, “Oh, you’re looking for a marketing person, or a senior marketing-level position, you need to talk to this person.” It’s like, “Oh, I’ve already got a few people. I’ll get them to submit their resume,” as opposed to, “Oh, my gosh, you need to speak to the velocity architect.”

All of a sudden, this person is different and unique. They stand out. You’re at least willing to entertain having a dialogue with them. And then the next thing is this concept that I came up with which was a champion relationship, which is somebody that is far more advanced than you, that’s willing to share your praises and willing to endorse your work and give it credibility. Because if you’re the velocity architect, and you’ve got other people talking about what you do and why it’s amazing that are highly credible, and you network to find those people, then those people will allow you to constantly land work and create greater and greater success.

But what I really want to do is take a step back for a second and imagine that I’m a brand-new person. I’ve never had a job before. And I’m moving into just a customer service role. I’m just looking for a customer service role. If I applied for every customer service role under the sun, then I’ve got to have the best resume, I’ve got to interview really well, I’ve got to cite all the right things. I’m relying on a lot of luck to get that job, and, especially if I’m introverted.

Now, don’t get me wrong. I believe that introverts actually make the best salespeople, the best networkers, the best public speakers, the best leaders, but if I didn’t believe that, and I didn’t plan and prepare, which introverts are great at, but most often they prepare and plan in the wrong way, I might go and bumble my way through that interview, and hope that they can see the real value in me to hire me.

But if I, instead, said, “You know what, what I’m going to do instead is I’m going to focus on my passion. Maybe I’m really passionate about manufacturing organizations, and changing customer service in a manufacturing business. Well, then maybe I’ll only go for manufacturing-based interviews. And because of that, I can talk about my passion for the manufacturing space. I can talk about the mission that I’m on to transform the space. I can do more research to understand it more, and it makes me more relevant and more employable to that organization.”

And that is why it allows you to create far more success. This isn’t new stuff. If you say, “I’m a person that’s trying to get a client, and I’m a small business owner.” Well, if you niche down, you’re, of course, going to be seen as far more likely the only logical choice. And if you’ve got a message that resonates to that marketplace, of course, they’re going to be willing to pay you as a premium. Well, why is that different for a corporate job?

It’s not different. The truth is if they’d never heard of you, then separating yourself from the pack is the only thing that’s going to make sure you’re in the top three candidates to get that second interview. And that is why I recommend that you do this because what you want to do is you want to shine on your differences, and you want to be able to talk about your unique passion, your unique mission.

Oh, by the way, if you are going for an interview, the other thing you really want to understand is that in an interview, you think it’s all about you. It’s not. The biggest mistake you can do when you go into an interview is make it all about you. And, by the way, introverts hate talking about themselves, which is why interviews goes so poorly because they go into an interview and they think they’ve got to brag on themselves and talk about their credibility, yet, the truth is, the best way to be successful in a networking room, and in an interview, is to understand the organization that you’re working for and the objectives that they have, and then make your experience relevant to them, and talk about your care for helping organizations like them.

And, again, to do that, you have to think about your differences, your unique value, the specific marketplace that you love helping, like manufacturing, or the specific outcome that you love helping people get, like customer-centric velocity, and then make that relevant to the organizations you’re going for interviews with. But truthfully, it doesn’t just work for going for interviews. Getting promotions within current organizations has also worked tremendously well for us as well because you can share your difference and get stakeholder support within the organization for new initiatives or to create jobs within an organization you already work with. And we’ve seen that happen time and time again.

Pete Mockaitis
Matthew, that’s beautiful. There’s a whole lot here. Boy, let’s chat about coming up with your unique point of view. And you said one way is that you kind of find the intersection. We’ve got an issue that you’re into, and an industry that you’re serving. So, not just customer service for anybody but customer service for manufacturing companies or whomever.

So, can you give us some examples of additional articulations of unique point of view? So, we got the velocity architect as one example. And how we come to land upon what that articulation is.

Matthew Pollard
Absolutely. So, I would say that you need to focus on what you’re absolutely passionate about. And there’s a quote by Jim Carrey that I think is great for those people that are worried that it’s not going to work. And he said, “I learned a great deal from my father but nothing more valuable than you can fail at what you don’t want, so why not take a chance at what you love?”

And so, I’m going to suggest to everybody when they’re looking at this articulation, to really think about what they’re passionate about, what they really care about. So, for somebody that really cares about manufacturing, go into the manufacturing space and build your messaging around that. If you’re really passionate about technology then build it around something specific that you do in the technology space. I’ll give you an example on that.

So, let’s imagine you’re a managed service provider, you work in an organization that you just love technology and you help people fix all their computers and systems, and you’re looking for a high-level CFO job, sorry, a CTO job. Well, maybe that what you really are passionate about doing is helping those companies obtain hyper growth. So, maybe you want to go and get a job at like an accounting organization that has a growth-through-acquisition mindset, or a lot of accounting firms grow by buying other accounting firms and taking on their books of business, or a manufacturing business will say, “Okay, we’ve got all these products. Let’s go and buy other manufacturing firms so that we can take on all their products but also cross-sell all the products that we have.”

So, growth through acquisition is really, really prevalent in those industries. So, if I was a CFO, and I was looking at those kinds of industries, and I love working with hyper growth companies, what I would say is the biggest problem that they have, though, and this happens a lot with organizations like that, is they buy a book of business, but then they’ve got to mix the technology. And what you’ll find is there’s licensing issues. The organization is building this fortress to make sure no one can hack in. And now they’ve got to build this hyper freeway to have all the data transferring between all these different offices, and it creates all these issues and conflicts.

Well, if I was going to sell to myself as an employee, I might position myself as the acquisition lifeguard because I know they want to grow through acquisition, and I know the technology is one of the biggest hassles that causes the organizations to almost drown in the minutiae of doing this that causes CEOs to lose their support. So, I might call myself the acquisition lifeguard in order to do that.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. Cool. So, you’ve got that clarity such that you become the only logical choice for a select few. And then it’s sort of like you have a moniker or a role or a title that goes there. Any tips on fine tuning that articulation? I think it’s so funny, I remember one time I was talking to someone, and he tried this. He said, “You know what, we’re a financial quarterback. You come to us and we’re going to find the best fixed income guy, the best stock picker, the best whatever.”

And it was so funny because I watch so little sports, I didn’t even understand the metaphor until much later, it’s like, “Oh, as a quarterback, your role is to throw the football or to pass a portion of my portfolio onto a specialist in different respects, much like a quarterback might throw to different players on the field.” I felt kind of like an idiot.

So, I guess, in a way, there’s a risk there that if you use a word that your target audience doesn’t have as much familiarity with, watch out for that. Any other pro tips on refining your moniker?

Matthew Pollard
So, there’s a couple of answers to that. So, firstly, you’re talking to an Australian with NFL terms so I have no idea what you’re talking about.

Pete Mockaitis
Oh, there you go. Yeah.

Matthew Pollard
I’ve lived in the United States for 10 years but I will tell you, I’m still getting my head around the NFL. But, yeah, I’m careful with the word quarterback. Also, I’ve worked with people in Germany, that you have to be careful about the word capitalist because it used to be a socialist society. You’ve really got to think things through.

But the thing that I would say is that if you use your functional skill in the unified message, then it’s not a unified message.

So, if you are in data analytics, and you call yourself the data wizard or the data guru, that’s not going to work for you and here’s the science behind it. People’s brains are focused on putting you into a box to disqualify you or to say, “I need that.” I’ll give you an example. If I go into a networking room, and I say I’m a sales trainer, people will look at me like I’m one step above a scam artist.

And if you’re my ideal avatar, you’re going to say, “Oh, I’m an introvert. I am never going to learn how to sell.” And then I’ve got to dance around that topic and explain how I’ve got a book that sold 100,000 copies helping introverts succeed at sales, and I’ve got to convince you. I’m already starting from behind. That doesn’t work.

And here’s the real key. The goal of the unified message is to do only this, “Hi, my name is Matthew, and I’m the rapid growth guy.” And I say it just like I said I’m an accountant or an attorney. The goal is for you to say it in a way that it feels like it really encapsulates the value of what you do. It feels more authentic. Like, for me, if I say I’m a sales trainer, it doesn’t incorporate the value of what I provide really at all. It’s just a functional skill. It’s like me reading a book, like Emeth, and saying, “Oh, I’m an Emeth person.” It doesn’t define you.

Everyone has got unique talents, unique skills, unique past backgrounds that perfectly qualify them to provide a certain value, and, more specifically, provide even more value to a specific demographic that they’re passionate about. And because of that, what you want to do, and the only thing that you want to focus on, is making sure that your unified message does one of two things. Either get them to say, “How do you do that?” or, “What exactly is that?” It’s to make it vague enough but also to provide interest.

Now, if you’re in a networking room and you’ve read my book, then you know to be interested before being interesting. So, if you’ve been talking to them for 20 minutes, and they say, “Oh, my gosh, Matthew, I’ve been talking to you for the last 20 minutes. I haven’t even asked you what it is that you do.” And you say, “Oh, thanks for asking. I’m the rapid growth guy.” Well, of course, they’re going to want to ask what that is for two reasons.

You’re a puzzle they need to solve, and, secondly, you gave them so much value by being interested in them, they want to give you value back by listening to you. So, that when people then respond with, “What exactly is that?” I can then say, “Well, one of the things that I love to see more than anything in the world and go into my passion mission statement.” Now, notice, I didn’t say, “Well, I do this and I do this, or I have this skill set,” because, again, networking isn’t about talking about you. It’s about expressing your passion and your mission for transforming the world in some way, shape, or form, which is intoxicating for people.

So, let’s look at what a good unified message looks like. A good unified message has a word, and I’m always cognizant of using things like point guard or you said quarterback because those are country-specific, and also sometimes gender-specific, and also whether they’re interested in the sports. It’s complicated. Maven, architect, catalyst, all these kinds of words are, again, above an eighth-grade reading level but, truthfully, a lot of people that are trying to get high-level jobs, most of the people that you’re talking to will understand what they are, but also expresses the value of what you provide in some way, shape, or form.

And, look, you don’t need to hire me to do this. If you’re a small business trying to come up with your version of the rapid growth guy or a career executive, there is a template that I share at MatthewPollard.com/growth, and that will give you a five-step process which will help you, firstly, determine the niche.

And, by the way, if you’re a career professional and you think that you don’t need to niche, you are 100% wrong. If you specialize in an industry, especially when you’re first starting, you’re always going to get paid a higher premium, you’re always going to be able to get headhunted more effectively, and then, over time, you can broaden that niche but this will show you how to niche down as a career professional or as a small business owner, and discover your niche of willing to buy clients or willing to buy employers. And then it will show you how to create your unified message that will excite and inspire people to want to know more.

And it really is about leaning in to your unique passions, your unique skillset, your unique past customers or past employers, and saying, “What was I really good at? What unique situations caused my employers or my past customers to sing my praises, to talk about me in a really positive way?” and really looking at how to then articulate it.

Now, once you’ve got that, you then need to know how to articulate your passion and mission in a way that gets people to be even more interested, and then you need to explain your value for the first time, the jargon of what you do in a story. And if you can do all of that in an interview, in a networking event, or a podcast interview like this, then people will chase you from all over the world to hire you or to get you to be their consultant or their small business guru.

You pick your profession because people these days are actively looking for a message that they identify with. And for that, they’ll pay a premium. The problem is that in today’s overly cluttered world, most people still only push vanilla content, like they come at high skill, or, “We know insurance,” or, “I’m a marketing person, and I’ve got 20 years of experience,” and the truth is, if you can’t be the clearest, you have to be the loudest.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. And you mentioned building relationships with momentum partners and champion relationships. Any pro tips on identifying these people and making the approach?

Matthew Pollard
Absolutely. And, by the way, introverts listening to this, you should love the idea of this because it means you’re going to networking events and not looking to be transactional. What I find is a lot of extroverts do this, which is they’ll go into a networking room, and they’re like, “Do you want to buy from me? What about you? What about you? Or, are you looking for somebody to hire? What about you? What about you?”

A lot of extroverts don’t like doing that either. They feel like it’s transactional but that then leads into what I call endless networking, which is where you don’t kind of downplay yourself. It’s, like, somebody asks you what you’re doing, you’re like, “Oh, my day job is this.” I mean, who wants to hire someone like that?

So, because of that, what I suggest is be more strategic about the networking events that you go to. So, firstly, a lot of people that go networking, they don’t do any research before they go, and that drives me crazy. It’s, like, if you’re going to go to a networking event, especially if you’re an introvert, which means it’s a little bit more uncomfortable, I want it to be more like a bunch of pre-planned meetings than anything else.

So, let’s talk about how that actually works. I spoke at Intel a few years ago, and I deliver this presentation about how storytelling could be used for marketing and from a sales perspective.

One of these executives came up to me afterwards, and he said, “Matt, look, I’ve really loved my conversation with you.” He said, “I can’t talk to anyone that’s here as easily because I don’t know anything about them. Like, after your presentation, I had lots of things to talk about. As an introvert, I had lots of questions I wanted to ask.”

And I said, “Well, I’m confused. Like, from what I know about Intel, you’re classified as a newbie if you’ve been there for less than 20 years.” I said, “You’re part of the top 100 senior leaders in sales and marketing. I would assume that you’ve done this before.” He’s like, “Oh, we do it every year, but every year I still awkwardly connect with people.” And I’m like, “Well, isn’t there like a guest list? Like, couldn’t you connect with them beforehand, find out strategically which people are a part of internal groups or associations that you might be interested in, and then research what books they’ve posted about, or what they’re posting on their LinkedIn profiles?”

So, if you’re an executive that’s listening to this, I don’t want you to think that internally this is impossible. You can, these days, search everything about a person. I remember I was trying to get sponsorship off Dell, and I found one of the senior leaders had an open Instagram profile, and all he did was publicly talk about how much he loved Peloton.

Well, I’m a runner, and it was wintertime in Texas. It’s freezing to run outside. So, we were in a conversation, and he said, “How are you?” I said, “Oh, I’m great. I wish I could go running. The weather is terrible.” And for the next 20 minutes, all he did was talk to me about Peloton and how amazing it was. He would’ve bought anything I said to him after that because I was so interested in what he was talking about.

So, the first thing is that all relationships come from pre-research so that you go into networking events with a little bit of due diligence. And if you go into an interview, by the way, if you know who’s interviewing you, you do some due diligence on the person, not just the company. But then when you go to a networking event, you’ve got to look that people really fit into three boxes, “Who could be a potential client or who could potentially employ me?” And that will get you a short-term win, if you’re a small business owner, of money coming in the door.

But momentum partners, they need to hear something different. They don’t want to hear about your functional skill. They want to understand the difference you want to make in the world in a way that they can articulate to other people. And then they want to understand a simple way of sharing that. Now, a momentum partner is, and these are informal relationships, it’s not a tit-for-that thing. But if I believe in what you do, I might start recommending you to other people that I know that you would get value from connecting with, and you would for me. These are people that are around the same credibility level as me or lower.

On the other hand, champion relationships are a kind of like the senior leaders. For me, Ivan Misner, the founder of BNI, is an amazing champion for me. He’s endorsed my books, he’s had me speak at his conference, he’s constantly talking about how great my work is, he’s had me on his podcast twice. He and I are great friends but, truthfully, if he called me tomorrow and said, “Fly to Texas. I need you to pick up my drycleaning,” I would do it. These are the relationships you want to foster.

So, what you need to understand about these relationships is they don’t want to know how much you know. They want to know how much you care. So, I’ll give you an example. If I’m in a networking event, and I introduce myself as the rapid growth guy, well, most people would say, “You know, I’m a marketer, and I specialize in customer-centric engagements for a large corporation,” or something horrible like that. It’s so, “I, I, I,” it’s so transactional.

Where what I will do is I’ll say, “I’m the rapid growth guy,” and when people ask me, “What exactly is that?” I will say, “Well, one of the things I love to see more than anything in the world is an amazing introverted service provider with enough talent, skill, and belief in themselves to start a business of their own. But what I find, more often than not, is they constantly get stuck in this endless hamster wheel of struggling to find interested people, trying to set themselves apart, trying to make the sale, feeling like people only care about one thing – price. Do you know anyone like that?”

Now, if I’ve done my research before, I’ve likely connected with these people in advance, there’s familiar faces in the room, I’ve walked up to them to talk to them. I know they’re like that. So, because of that, they’ll respond in the affirmative. And then when they say, “Well, yeah, absolutely. I’m like that,” and I’ll say, “Well, I’m on a mission to help introverts like yourself, realize you’re not a second-class citizen.”

“Your path to success is just different to that of an extrovert, and rapid growth really comes down to three steps outside the scope of your functional skill, which you’re usually amazing at. And if you just focus on these three steps, you really can build a rapid growth business that revolves around you, your family, and your life, not the other way around.” 

And because of that, momentum partners and champions will go, “Wow, I want to introduce you to so-and-so. Or, have you thought about joining this association or this support group or this initiative that we’re having? I want to have you as part of it.” Because people are so used to getting so bored with these mundane introductions of what you do.

And when they hear passion, “I love to see this, I hate to see this, and I’m on a mission to do this,” for the first time, it is intoxicating and they will open up their rolodex for you. And, depending on whether they’re a momentum partner, i.e., the same level or below as you, or a champion, a higher level, the doors that they will open will be compelling. And, especially, you’ve been interested before interesting, and offering people in your rolodex, offering to just give them value in any way, shape, or form that you can beforehand, you will find that all of the doors will open for you, and you’ll create relationships like you’ve never seen before.

Pete Mockaitis
All right. Well, Matthew, tell me, anything else you want to make sure to mention before we hear about some of your favorite things?

Matthew Pollard
Firstly, there’s nothing wrong with being an introvert. But, secondly, it’s not something you can change. 

Introversion is just this – where you draw your energy from. That’s it. It doesn’t mean you can’t engage in small talk. It doesn’t mean the strategies of small talk are different. And if you try to copy extroverts, my gosh, it’s going to be a really uncomfortable inauthentic feeling that you’ll have afterwards, and that’s why a lot of us ruminate afterwards.

But what I want you to know if you’re an introvert is, firstly, you’re not a second-class citizen.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. Now, could you share with us a favorite quote, something you find inspiring?

Matthew Pollard
My favorite quote, is that “We can change who we are at every moment.” We get a second chance every second.

Pete Mockaitis
All right. And a favorite study or experiment or bit of research?

Matthew Pollard
There’s a Stanford study that says when we tell a story, it activates the reticular activating system of the brain, which means that the brain, between the storyteller and the story receiver, actually synchronize. It creates artificial rapport which we introverts can create into deeper rapport.

Pete Mockaitis
All right. And a favorite book?

Matthew Pollard
I really loved Rich Dad, Poor Dad. I felt like that was a really great book for all people, whether they’re entrepreneurs or career professionals. I feel like it’s a really great book for everybody.

Pete Mockaitis
All right. And a favorite tool, something you use to be awesome at your job?

Matthew Pollard
I actually love at the moment ChatGPT. It’s providing a ton of value for a lot of different things at the moment.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. And a favorite habit?

Matthew Pollard
So, for me, I think planning is my favorite habit. And I think for introverts, I think that planning is absolutely essential because, otherwise, you’ll go into a sale and you’re uncomfortable. For me, any day that I feel like I’ve got anxiety or stress, it means that I’m moving away from my goals. So, I will re-read over my goals.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. And is there a key nugget you share that really seems to connect and resonate with folks; they tweet it, they Kindle book highlight it, etc., the say, “Matthew, that was so brilliant and touching when you said this thing”?

Matthew Pollard
The words “Introverts are not second-class citizens. Our path to success is just different to that of an extrovert.” And then you say right after that, “And I am an introvert, I should know.” And then tell your personal story, and my bet is you will find out that many of your bosses are also introverted so it will help you move up the ladder but also will inspire so many people below you to believe they can.

Pete Mockaitis
All right. And if folks want to learn more or get in touch, where would you point them?

Matthew Pollard
Go to MatthewPollard.com/growth, download that template, and create that unified message, and discover your niche of willing to buy clients, or discover your niche of employer, and create a unified message.

My books are a great resource. Just go to TheIntrovertsEdge.com, download the first chapter, and I literally help you believe that you can sell, and then give you the exact process.

Pete Mockaitis
All right. Thank you, Matthew. This has been a treat. I wish you much fun networking.

Matthew Pollard
It was my absolute pleasure. Thanks for having me on.

868: Fostering the Sense of Community at Work with Christine Porath

By Podcasts No Comments

 

Christine Porath says: "Too many people don’t feel any sense of community."

Christine Porath discusses why community is critical to well-being and shares powerful examples of how to build it in the workplace.

You’ll Learn:

  1. The astounding benefits of a sense of community
  2. The one thing to avoid with community-building activities
  3. How vulnerability leads to richer communities

About Christine

Christine Porath is a tenured professor at Georgetown University’s McDonough School of Business. She’s the author of Mastering Civility: A Manifesto for the Workplace and co-author of The Cost of Bad Behavior. Christine is a frequent contributor to the Harvard Business Review, and has written articles for New York Times, Wall Street Journal, McKinsey Quarterly, and Washington Post. She frequently delivers talks and has taught in various Executive programs at Harvard, Georgetown, and USC. Prior to her position at Georgetown, she was a faculty member at University of Southern California’s Marshall School of Business.

Christine’s work has been featured worldwide in over 1500 television, radio and print outlets. It has appeared on 20/20, Today, FoxNews, CNN, BBC, NBC, msnbc, CBS, ABC, and NPR. It has also been included in Time, the Wall Street Journal, the Financial Times, Fortune, Forbes, NY Times, The Washington Post, and L.A. Times.

Resources Mentioned

Pete Mockaitis
Christine, welcome to How to be Awesome at Your Job.

Christine Porath
Thanks for having me.

Pete Mockaitis
I’m excited to dig into your wisdom and hear some juicy tidbits from your latest Mastering Community: The Surprising Ways Coming Together Moves Us from Surviving to Thriving. So, for starters, could you maybe share with us a really cool story that has some nifty surprises that illustrates what’s up with community, like what’s at stake and what’s possible and what’s the goodness that we might want to be able to tap into?

Christine Porath
Sure. So, it really was inspired by my brother and sister-in-law’s story. So, in 2008, my brother, Mike, and his wife, Sarah, had a truly terrible life changing day. In the morning, a doctor informed them that their unborn child was missing a kidney, and possibly other organs. And then in the afternoon, they returned home and there was even more devastating news. They had learned from their doctor that their two-year-old daughter, Annabelle, had a rare chromosome disorder, Dup15q, and her mind would probably not develop beyond that of a five-year-old.

And so, feeling lost and scared, my brother turned to Google to try to learn more about this diagnosis, and most of the guidance he found online wasn’t that helpful, but he clicked an old PDF file containing six stories from parents whose children experienced similar disabilities. And the stories contained joy and humor, and they offered reason for hope. And if these parents could cope with these disabilities and even find some joy in the process, maybe Mike and his wife figured they could, too.

And after conquering another parenting challenge with Annabelle, just a couple of months later, Mike realized that solutions could be simple because he had, again, posted online to try to get answers, and that’s where he found them. There was a woman who posted how to teach a child a pincer grasp, how to pick up food, which Annabelle was struggling with. And what Mike realized after trying what she suggested, which was cutting two holes, a sock for her forefinger, a sock for her thumb, and putting Annabelle’s favorite food in the tray, that it didn’t take very long, less than a month, for Annabelle to master that.

And so, through those instances, Mike realized that, oftentimes, lived experience rather than professional expertise can go a long way. And wasn’t it wonderful that communities, in this case of parents suffering with similar disabilities or diagnoses, were helping each other? And so, in 2014, Mike and Sarah bootstrapped a new venture called The Mighty, which is a digital media company connecting people facing disease, disabilities, disorders.

And since then, The Mighty has grown from just a tiny tribe of people to several million people that connect online to help each other, lift each other up. And one of the things that I learned from Mike was that, while groups under The Mighty work created to address specific needs, beyond that they were really solving for the problem of isolation and loneliness.

And I think too many people, I realized, even in the workplace, feel like Mike did, alone or disconnected and suffering, and it was just really inspiring to me to see how they were able to build community from the ground up, and how it’s helped so many people. And since I study stuff in the workplace and I got a frontline seat to see how that evolved, I just was seeing data saying too many people don’t feel any sense of community, about 65%, at work. And this was all pre-pandemic, of course.

And so, I just felt like we could and should do better. And what could we learn from The Mighty and other places like it?

Pete Mockaitis
Well, so a couple quick clarifiers, 65% don’t feel any sense of community anywhere or at work?

Christine Porath
At work.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. Got you. And this pincer grasp, not that it’s a parenting podcast but I got to know. So, I get a sock and I cut two holes in it, and then that’s the trick, it’s like we got two fingers to work with?

Christine Porath
That’s the trick. And you put a sock on the other hand so there’s no cheating involved, and then you have at it. You put favorite food in a tray and, apparently, that’s the way to get at this. So, it was pretty interesting given that so many physicians and experts and others were trying to help them and nothing was working. And so, it was one of those things where maybe some parents that were facing similar situations knew best.

Pete Mockaitis
I really like that a lot, and I guess I’m discovering that nowadays that when it comes to doing research, what turns up when you ask a friend versus Reddit, versus a Facebook group, versus Google, versus ChatGPT, are quite different. And sometimes with the search engines, I don’t know how to articulate it, but it seems like the top results are often the ones that have put a lot of effort into becoming the top results in terms of their budgets and their search engine optimizers and all that stuff. And the sock pincer insight is not all that monetizable, and so there’s a good chance it’ll not find its way onto the front page of search engine results.

Christine Porath
Yeah. And so, I think one of the things that they learned was just how helpful community can be around similar issues or struggles or that kind of thing. And so, I think we could learn the same from workplace situations as well. What if we had other people to lean on and glean information from who cared about us or cared about our situation?

Pete Mockaitis
And so then in workplaces, how does that often materialize? Is it within one workplace, like the employer, like Microsoft or Google? Or is it sort of a community, like an association across many employers? How do you see those things working?

Christine Porath
Well, I think it could be either but, really, I was looking to try within organizations, try to build communities. So, at a Microsoft, or at a Motley Fool, or at a small company that people might be able to really feel a sense of belonging and feel like they matter, that they cared, that others around them cared about them, and how that could make a real difference on things like engagement. So, there was incentives for leaders to pay attention to were they building communities where people feel connected also?

Pete Mockaitis
So, let’s talk about some of these metrics. Any particularly eye-popping statistics or findings from research? Like, what is the difference that having a great community versus not so much of a community really makes at work?

Christine Porath
Well, we found, when people feel connected with their colleagues, they’re 74% more engaged and 81% more likely to stay with the organization. They’re also far more likely to thrive at work, which we know is connected to performance and things like that. And this was data from over 20,000 people that Tony Schwartz and I collected. So, it ranged across different organizations, across different industries, it was global, so fairly generalizable.

Pete Mockaitis
Yeah, Tony Schwartz from The Power of Full Engagement?

Christine Porath
Yes, exactly.

Pete Mockaitis
Beautiful.

Christine Porath
Yeah, and The Energy Project where he founded that.

Pete Mockaitis
Yeah, we’ve had him on and he’s swell. Okay. So, then could you paint a picture for us, inside a work context, do we have a nice illustration of what a great community story looks, sounds, and feels like in practice?

Christine Porath
Well, I think one that is from a smaller organization that I’m pretty familiar with now is Motley Fool, and they’re a best place to work. And one of the things that they do, they have lots of fitness challenges, which are fun, and that kind of thing, but they organize a lot of events where they show up for each other. One of the things that they did, I know, through the pandemic was they realized that people liked to actually teach one another things that they care about, like hobbies.

And so, even on Zoom, they might sign up for something that they felt like they could teach people about. And it ranged anywhere from how to knit, to butchery-type stuff, to all different sorts of things. And what they found is that it really created a sense of community, both the person teaching as well as the person learning. And so, it was a way to increase engagement driven solely by people and what they wanted to connect with others about. So, I like that because it was, really, doesn’t require a lot of resources, and both the learner and teacher benefit. So, that was one that popped.

Pete Mockaitis
That is fun. Can you share another example?

Christine Porath
Sure. The book is full of examples. I think one that comes to mind is Marriott has a TakeCare program, and they’re global. After their merger, they have over 700,000 employees, and yet on the ground, locally, they have what are called TakeCare ambassadors. And those folks in a particular location, let’s say Thailand, on the beach there, they would organize activities that they felt like would contribute to the wellbeing of their employees but also the wellbeing of the community.

So, they might do something around protection of sea turtles, or cleaning up the beach, or painting schools that needed that kind of care. But the idea was that they were often doing something for the local community or that would benefit people. They would have painting bike helmets for kids, and so host these events for local citizens and things like that.

So, I think I’ve seen a lot of doing good for the outside community, which generates a sense of thriving and pride and feeling connected to their coworkers and their organization in a meaningful way.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. Now, I’m curious, in practice, when leaders, either very senior or mid level in terms of managing a team, hear this stuff, and think, “Ooh, that’s cool. We should do that,” what are some of the key differentiators that make community-building efforts meaningful and enriching and impactful in the ways we’re going for versus some that kind of miss the mark or feel fake or off?

Christine Porath
Well, I think one that’s gone over well is at Traeger, eating together or cooking together, and they really looked to, with a new headquarters, they cook together six days a week. And I think it’s different from, necessarily, having food on site to try to keep people there for a lot of hours and things like that. But it’s, literally, they’ll make breakfast, I believe, it’s on Monday, and then lunches all the other days together.

And so, from all data and anecdotes shared, that’s a really nice value that they benefit from and enjoy each other’s company. And there’s research behind the fact that cooking together and eating together is a way to form collaboration, get to know each other better, and ends up helping things like performance and so forth. And some of that research was done with firefighters but I think I’ve really seen it take root in different organizations in meaningful ways.

One differentiator at Traeger might also be the fact that the leaders, including the CEO, Jeremy Andrus, participates and is involved in the Monday meetings that they have, which incorporate a lot of peer awards for living the values and things like that. So, I think that that can make a difference, like leaders not only encouraging certain aspects of, let’s say, sustainability or things like that, sustainable work practices, but role-model it as well.

And so, I think that with Tony Schwartz, that was another finding that we had among that large dataset was it’s really important when leaders not only encourage these practices but live them as well, setting the tone for it.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. And then do you have some examples of attempts at community gone wrong where this wasn’t landing with folks, like, “Yeah, this is kind of lame, or awkward, or uncomfortable, or unnatural, and we don’t like this”?

Christine Porath
I think, generally speaking, it’s when they’re forced and mandatory.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay, “We’re all having fun now.”

Christine Porath
Yeah, exactly. That you have to participate, that these are after-hour events that you feel like if you’re not there, it’s punishable kind of thing, but those are the ones that come to mind. It’s almost like the forced workplace, you have to do work from the office versus having some flexibility. So, similarly, I think around community events, like, ideally, people have some choice around them.

Pete Mockaitis
Yeah, I remember one time at work, we went golfing, and so I made it very clear that I, straight up, don’t know how to play golf, and that when I’ve attempted, it went very poorly in terms of, like, divots everywhere, so, like, “Just so we’re clear.” And so then, they’re like, “Oh, you’ll be fine.” I was like, “Well, okay, if you say so. I’ve told you sort of what’s going to happen.”

And then I did it and then they were very frustrated with me, and then they’re like, “We’ve got to let them play through. You’re slowing us down.” I was like, “Well, I kind of told you that was how this was going to go.” And so, I found that very uncomfortable and unpleasant in terms of that experience, as opposed to, I don’t know, either choosing a different activity that everyone likes, or just say, “Okay. Well, hey, check this out. Well, you can hang out on the golf cart and goof around and have some drinks, I don’t know, whatever, and enjoy things that way even if the actual swinging of the club isn’t in the cards for the day.”

So, yeah, that’s a good point. So, there’s a choice, it’s not mandatory. And it seems like with the cooking example, and it’s come up before. It’s like folks are doing stuff collaboratively, and so I think there’s probably some magic there. I’m thinking now about Bob Cialdini and his stuff about singing and/or dancing in unison does cool stuff. That might be harder, I don’t know, depending on the vibe of your workplace. Folks might be really into that or not at all.

And so, I guess that’s maybe one of the themes, is that this will be very individualistic for individuals and teams based on what vibes for them.

Christine Porath
Yeah, I think I really like your example of having some choice around different activities, for example. I’ve seen that go over really well. Or, even if you plan an event, like I attended one at a major league baseball park that they rented out the area where you can eat together and so forth, then you could tour the field. This was an evening activity. The batting cages were open so it was really fun for those of us that wanted to take a crack at swinging against some pitchers, but you didn’t have to.

You could hang out and eat or drink with others. You could walk around and tour the facilities. So, it could be a number of different things that you could do even though there was a large room together where people could hang out. So, it provided a little bit of choose your own path depending on your interests and your abilities and so forth that seem to go over really well as far as most people being happy with the choices and that kind of things.

So, I think that that choice element that you highlighted is really key, if possible. And I know for offsites, oftentimes what they’ll do is just people can choose out of three, four, five activities. And I think that’s a really nice way to promote inclusivity as well, the idea that, depending on your capabilities, cultural differences, interests, those kinds of things, you’re providing a number of different paths for people.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. So, beyond the activities or the outings, are there any other key ingredients in the mix for having great communities at work?

Christine Porath
I think anytime that you can promote healthier living and provide some sense of, whether it’s recovery or rejuvenation or things like that, those are wins as well. I think of Kelly McGonigal’s The Joy of Movement and the idea of that that’s a nice thing for people that are interested in that, but they’re amplifiers, like doing it together, doing it nature, doing it to music, things like that.

And so, one of the examples that I shared was a woman who actually started a program at Dell at the time around just because people were gaining a lot of weight, they weren’t feeling very good, she started covering them for working out an hour each day. And it ended up becoming, Thrive was the program, but people couldn’t wait to be a part of it.

And I think that part of it was it also broke down barriers, she said, of you might have a leader running next to someone that was in the call center, and it tended to break down silos in the organization, and build, cultivate relationships among people that might not have, otherwise, known each other or gotten to meet one another, and so that was a real positive as well as people became far healthier in terms of practices and things like that.

So, that was a nice example that I liked a lot. It doesn’t work for everyone but I think it, overall, had a lot of positive effects for various individuals, and team performance shot up and things like that. So, even though that they were working less or had the capability to work less, given time off to take a break, to work out, things like that, then, overall, it was a real win for the organization.

Pete Mockaitis
And you also mentioned radical candor. We had Kim Scott on the show, and she was swell. But what role does that play in building community? And could you give us some examples?

Christine Porath
Yeah, I love Kim Scott’s work on radical candor, and some of the examples that I share in the book actually tie to Kelly Leonard, who’s at Second City. And he and Kim partnered to teach people radical candor through improvisation and the idea that we’re all a work in progress. But I think radical candor, when people know that you care personally, there’s more liberty to challenge directly.

And I think that that’s a positive as far as we want people sharing feedback, we want people, basically, coaching each other up, like helping people improve. And a great way to do that is through radical candor, given how negative feedback is often awkward for a lot of us. And so, if you can develop a spirit of radical candor, it really helps quite a bit.

And one of the examples that I liked in the book came from Christa Quarles, who, at the time, was CEO of OpenTable. And one of the things that she shared was she learned she had to give it to get it. In other words, she had to be vulnerable and share when she has messed up or needed feedback, and that kind of broke down some of the barriers, such that people were able to see, “Okay, she can handle that kind of criticism or direct feedback. And what happens if we use it?”

But I think she also had to encourage it along the way, suggesting that, “Listen, failure is okay. Like, through failure, we will learn. So, some of that criticism is actually welcome because it’s going to get us to a better place more quickly.” And so, I thought she handled things really well. And if folks were not comfortable speaking up, one of the things that she did was pulled them aside.

Like, this very talented woman who just was reluctant to speak up in a group, and she coached her effectively, and she just let her know, “Listen, if I need to, I’ll tee you up for this, but we need you. We need your voice. We need you involved,” and it really went a long way to developing her but, more importantly at the time, also what the team and the organization needed.

And so, I thought it was an excellent example of leaders as a coach, and getting involved to kind of get the ball rolling for people to be radically candid in ways that maybe didn’t come naturally, but they needed to break out of what Christa Quarles called ruinous empathy, or this idea of not speaking up because you don’t want to hurt someone, which is the most common mistake. And I think Kim says that about 85% of the mistakes are in that arena.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. And speaking of mistakes, we talked about not having the forced fun. Is there any other top do’s and don’ts you’d highlight if folks are thinking, “Yeah, I would like to kick up some community at work”? What do you recommend as being some of the very first things they do do and they don’t do?

Christine Porath
Well, I think the idea of uniting people and providing a safe space for people to communicate is huge, and leaders can set the tone for that by being vulnerable, admitting mistakes, admitting failures, things like that. But one of the examples that I used at the beginning of the book is just an example of Phil Jackson, who, you may know, coaching the Chicago Bulls for all those years and winning so many championships.

But Steve Kerr talked about one of the things that brought them to be such a tight knit team was the idea that every day they met in Phil’s kind of film room, so to speak, but they wouldn’t talk about basketball or the X’s and O’s. It was all about connecting. And so, I think that idea of, “Are you providing a safe space where people are communicating and getting to know each other in different ways?”

That could be around activities. It could be around cooking like we talked about. There are so many different ideas behind that, but I think bringing people together and trying to create a place where people can be vulnerable is really huge. So, I liked that example for the idea that just get people talking, sharing information, and that kind of thing.

Another example that I liked was Chuck Robbins at Cisco, and the idea of having a conscious culture. And one of the things that they did, again, well before the pandemic, was they had a program called Love and Load. And the idea was that people would be providing how they were doing, so just a quick full survey, and the leader would get that data and could really quickly address it.

So, if someone was kind of struggling or not having a good week, a leader could check in really quickly around that. And so, I think it’s helping to create touchpoints between leaders and their direct reports, or even peers for that matter, but the idea of being, I think, people need those kinds of little lifts. And so, the more that the leader can create these touchpoints through the day, which Doug Conant talks about quite a bit and has a book on touchpoints, and really turned an organization, Campbell Soup, around with touchpoints. That would be a really good mode to kind of jumpstart things.

It doesn’t take a lot of time. These were moments that Doug talked about in the hallways, in meetings, in the cafeteria, and it was all about connecting with people, and you listen attentively. He would often try to leverage his expertise and then close with, “How can I help?” And those kinds of moments really made a difference.

Another one that Doug talked about, which I love, was he ended up sending 30,000 thank you notes while CEO of Campbell’s. And I think that’s something that, especially nowadays where people may be feeling a little beat down, or a little negative, or just struggling coming off of the pandemic, well, even before that, this was important, but the point is that these thank you notes made a huge difference in making people feel valued.

And so, those small things can make a huge difference in employees’ lives, and get them engaged, get them, retain them in organizations. And it was kind of fun. I had a friend that a few months ago was traveling on a plane and sat behind a gentleman who was raving about where he worked, at Campbell’s, and the fact that 15 years ago, a CEO had written this lowly salesperson a thank you note.

And so, again, 15 years later, someone is still talking about this, still proud of the company, the connections, the sense of community that he felt because of this action. So, I think that small actions can make a huge difference, and you don’t have to be a leader for that to happen.

Pete Mockaitis
That’s beautiful. Well, Christine, tell me, anything else you want to make sure to mention before we shift gears and hear about some of your favorite things?

Christine Porath
I think the idea of ubuntu, and, “I am who I am because of who we all are.” I like that idea a lot. And as you may be able to tell, I like sports examples a lot. So, I shared an example of Doc Rivers turning around the Boston Celtics at the time with this rallying cry. But I also love the example, and it was actually the woman, Carla Peñarosa Blatt, who I shared the Dell story about, who found that by taking time out and traveling with her family, not wired into technology and things like that, she and her family really felt a much greater sense of connectedness.

And I think, for her, it was kind of putting away the technology even for short periods of time and really trying to connect with people. And, again, it could be short, over coffee, over a meal. It could be in the backyard, over campfire, what have you. But the point being that the importance of maybe disconnecting from all of our tasks, the technology, so that we can connect better and feel a sense of community.

So, again, I think that that’s something that doesn’t necessarily require huge resources but is an action that could make a big difference in our lives as far as the quality of connection and community that we feel.

Pete Mockaitis
All right. Thank you. Well, now could you share a favorite quote, something you find inspiring?

Christine Porath
I have one quote at the beginning of the book that I like a lot that’s actually from Brene Brown, and it’s just the idea of unlocking our potential. So, I believe it is, “You can’t unlock potential if you cannot unlock people.” So, she’s written about this, which I love.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. And a favorite study or experiment or bit of research?

Christine Porath
I think you hit all on the radical candor part that I talk a lot about with respect to respect. The other bit is just how rudeness or incivility is contagious. And so, I often cite that but the good news is civility is contagious as well. And so, again, kind of pointing to small actions and how, for better or worse, they have a lot of different ripple effects and can change how our communities feel. So, I hope that’s empowering for people.

Pete Mockaitis
All right. And a favorite book?

Christine Porath
Man’s Search for Meaning.

Pete Mockaitis
And a favorite tool?

Christine Porath
I like Tony Schwartz’s Energy Audit, or, more generally, just checking in to see how you feel throughout the day, and making adjustments accordingly.

Pete Mockaitis
All right. And a favorite habit?

Christine Porath
For me, it’s probably working out, ideally, in the morning to get a jumpstart and feeling good.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. And is there a key nugget you share that really seems to connect and resonate with folks; they quote it back to you often?

Christine Porath
I use an example of the 10-5 way which was if people were within 10 feet, they smiled and made eye contact. If they were within five feet, they said hello. And what OSHA healthcare system found is that people felt a stronger sense of civility but also patient satisfaction scores rose as did patient referrals. And so, I just like the idea that it kinda shows how contagion happens even outside of the organization in ways that really help people within and outside organizations to kind of lift them up.

Pete Mockaitis
And if folks want to learn more or get in touch, where would you point them?

Christine Porath
Probably LinkedIn, so just Christine Porath. And I’m on Twitter @PorathC.

Pete Mockaitis
Okay. And do you have a final challenge or call to action for folks looking to be awesome at their jobs?

Christine Porath
I think the idea of think about, “Who do you want to be in different moments?” and just what can we do to lift others up throughout our day.

Pete Mockaitis
All right. Christine, this has been a treat. Thank you. I wish you much luck and good community.

Christine Porath
Thank you. I appreciate the opportunity to be on your show.