
Dr. Cindi Baldi shares expert strategies to stay calm and confident in the face of uncertainty.
You’ll Learn
- How uncertainty influences us without us realizing
- How to power through our bias for risk aversion
- The simple habit that builds your wisdom
About Cindi
Dr. Cindi Baldi is the founder and CEO of Culsure, an organizational science firm, co-host of the Management Muse podcast, and co-author of The Uncertainty Playbook. Cindi is an expert in organizational behavior, group performance, and employee identification, with research presented globally at leading institutions. She develops science-based culture and leadership assessments used across corporate, nonprofit, and government organizations, and advises leaders worldwide on improving performance, culture, and team effectiveness.
- Book: The Uncertainty Playbook: 14 Strategies for Work Success in a Chaotic World
- Podcast: Management Muse
- Website: Culsure.com
Resources Mentioned
- Theory: Uncertainty-Identity Theory
- Book: Thinking in Bets: Making Smarter Decisions When You Don’t Have All the Facts by Annie Duke
- Book: Simple Truths: Clear & Gentle Guidance on the Big Issues in Life by Kent Nerburn
- Past episode: 614: Making Smarter Decisions When You Can’t Know Everything with Annie Duke
- Past episode: 981: Using AI to Enhance Your Reading, Notes, Memory, and Decisions with Kwame Christian
Cindi Baldi Interview Transcript
Pete Mockaitis
Cindi, welcome!
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Thank you. Thank you for having me.
Pete Mockaitis
Well, I am excited to talk about uncertainty. You got a whole playbook for us. I’d love it if you could kick us off by sharing what is one of the most surprising things you’ve discovered about us humans and uncertainty in all your research?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
So I think what surprised me is uncertainty plays like a huge silent role in so many of the decisions that we make and the important decisions, like which groups and hobbies and organizations we decide to work for.
Like, we basically are largely choosing, in a way, to minimize our uncertainty, including our career path. I mean, like most people I talk to, including myself, when you talk to them, there’s a story back there on how they chose their path, and it’s usually because the path was more visible to them than any others.
So I grew up in an entrepreneurial family, and I even went to get a PhD and went that track but, ultimately, still went back to entrepreneurship. And it was like a path that was more well known to me.
And then we’ve been in all sorts of hospitals and you talk to people in hospitals, and, inevitably, either they had somebody who was in the medical field and they saw the path, or somebody, themselves, or somebody they were really close to were really, really sick, and so they spent a tremendous amount of time around those people, and so the path became, you know, more visible to them.
And so I think that, to me, that’s the most interesting part about uncertainty. It’s just so much of our life is actually created around trying to reduce the uncertainty of life.
Pete Mockaitis
Cindi, that is a provocative assertion. I’m provoked. You have provoked me. Because I’m thinking, decisions are real important, in a way. And we’ve had Annie Duke on the show, the professional poker player, had a fabulous book, Thinking in Bets.
And, in many ways, our decisions are about the top thing that we want to get right. And in the universe, that is unpredictable, uncertain, luck, un-luck, showing up for us, what we decide is tremendously consequential, arguably the most important skill of them all.
And to hear that we are choosing, in a way, to minimize our uncertainty, my gut reaction is, “Huh, that doesn’t feel like the ‘optimal’ criterion we should be optimizing for in our decision-making.” And yet we often are. Can you share, do you have any intriguing research or studies that backs up that assertion further?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
So there’s a classic researcher, Michael Hogg, and he’s the one who first turned me on to even thinking about uncertainty as the role. And, basically, to summarize what I recall about his research, is that the groups that can reduce our uncertainty are the ones that we’re most likely to actually identify with and identify strongly with.
And so, it’s this idea that drawing people into groups is often related to just at, like, “How much certainty can you provide?”
So you think about, and I’m going to be provocative here, I guess, because of the topic, but you think about religion.
Pete Mockaitis
Oh, yeah, I thought that first, yeah.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Yeah, so that is great, like that’s the fundamental uncertainty, “What happens on the other side?” And for people who are very uncomfortable with that uncertainty, to some degree, they are seeking out a religious group and they often very, very strongly identify with that religious group.
And if you talk to them, they’ll tell you they feel like they know what’s happening on the other side. So I have very religious people in my family, and they absolutely feel like they know where they’re going on the other side and that they know the rules in order to get in.
Pete Mockaitis
Well, yeah, I was thinking about that first in terms of that’s about as uncertain as it gets.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Yeah, it’s fundamental.
Pete Mockaitis
I mean, when you die, is there nothingness, eternal bliss, eternal torture? That’s the full. And it’s hard to know.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Or recycled. Or recycled.
Pete Mockaitis
Oh, sure. Okay. Reincarnated, yeah. And so, in terms of, like, it’s hard to know in terms of with the evidence we have available tangibly in front of us. It’s hard to know and the consequences are about as epic as they get.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
As they get.
Pete Mockaitis
So, yeah, that is like max uncertainty. And folks in their religious communities often feel quite close, connected to those, and that’s intriguing. And then, I’m thinking about if someone is in, say, a volleyball league or bowling league, those bonds, they’re certainly more than zero, but the amount of uncertainty that’s being alleviated is much less.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
I’m going to argue with you on that.
Pete Mockaitis
Okay.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
So, one of the things that I learned while at universities, I actually was at the University of Texas at Austin, when they were trying to figure out basically how to increase student retention, you know, like the freshmen that come in. They wanted to work on the number who leave shortly after entering.
And one of the things that they realized, they created these things that they called figs at the time. And I can’t remember what a fig actually means. But, basically, they broke students down into about 17 students and there were different tracks.
And they would have for, like, I think the first two years, at least one, possibly more classes together. It was the same 17 people going through.
And those students, because they were able to form relationships very fast, were less likely to leave. And, oftentimes, like I just had somebody who we’re very close to. He just graduated high school in May, and his high school is literally eight people.
And as I’m sitting there in the audience, I’m like, “Oh, my God, he doesn’t actually know how to make friends because it was just, it’s eight people.” Like, you’re going to know everybody.
Pete Mockaitis
Okay, yeah. It just happens.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Yeah. And so when the graduation was over, I pulled him aside, I said, “Listen, you’re going to a big university. What you need to do in order to make it digestible is you need to join groups. Find the groups that you actually want to do and have similar interests with people, but that’s how you break down and feel connected to a university that’s that big, is that you find the groups.”
And so, you know, joining a volleyball team, you wouldn’t think, “Well, it’s a hobby and I don’t have to do that.” But it’s a way that you’re finding people that you’re hanging out with an awful lot, which reduces your uncertainty socially. Like, “I have people I can turn to. I don’t have to worry about whether or not I have to eat by myself if I’m uncomfortable eating by myself,” for instance.
Pete Mockaitis
Yeah, I hear you, certainly. I guess, and if you’re in a context where you don’t know much of anyone, one hundred percent, I mean, any group will reduce a tremendous amount of uncertainty when you’re going from no group.
I was thinking in the context of grown folks living in their communities, it’s like, “Oh, maybe I’ll join a bowling league or a volleyball group.” And so those relationships are meaningful and valuable.
Though I’m guessing, most of the time, that’ll probably be not as intensely close than some other relationships which would reduce more uncertainty but that’s kind of speculative. But, understood, groups are hugely valuable in part because what they do is reduce all kinds of uncertainty for us.
And so, help us out. I understand, or at least I intuit and have heard before, that 2026 here, as we’re recording, seems to have, substantially, more uncertainty in it than, I don’t know, a decade ago, two, three, four decades ago. That’s the vibe I’m feeling. Is that the case from a research-driven perspective?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
I don’t know that I have seen any research specifically that says it’s ramped up, but it seems to me, anecdotally, that the speed of change has just increased drastically. And, I mean, like the technological, to me, you look back historically, and we’ve had huge technological advancements that, certainly, like shifted everything underneath somebody’s feet.
You know, even just like think about like the airplane, right? Like, that shifts where you can actually go in a fundamental way that is extraordinary. And then that opens up all sorts of opportunities, and not to mention resources.
And so we’ve certainly had that before, but it seems like the velocity of the change has increased. And that’s really what we’re talking about, is that every time there’s change, that creates uncertainty because we don’t really know how that change is going to impact all the different elements of our life, and we’re scrambling to keep up with that.
And it just seems like that’s the case. And then you look at AI and we’re in the middle of it, and it seems like it’s going to be as big or bigger than the internet, and yet, we don’t really fully understand how everything that’s going to change. I mean, like you can pontificate on it.
Pete Mockaitis
Oh, sure. And they love to.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Exactly. But if there’s no room for humans for jobs, just think about the impact of that. That’s like the most extreme, right? Then if robots are doing everything, if AI is doing everything, then our whole economic system, every economic system that we have a concept of out there – capitalism, socialism, communism – all of it doesn’t work.
And so that’s the potential for huge uncertainty. What would work with that? And I’m not saying that that’s what’s going to happen.
But that’s probably the most extreme case in terms of uncertainty and what would happen. And the only thing that I can say about that is, “Well, we’re all on the same boat, so we’ll be all going through it together.”
Pete Mockaitis
That’s true. That’s true.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
No one will have an advantage.
Pete Mockaitis
Yeah, no one knows what the future holds. And I find that so irritating when folks speak with such certainty about things that are fundamentally uncertain – the future. It’s like you could present some scenarios, yeah, but any or none or all of them could come to pass.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Right. And we just need to be in a place where we can be adaptable. And some of that is being able to manage yourself when there’s uncertainty around you. And so I think that’s why the book is timely. We didn’t make it for that. I mean, AI happened after we wrote it. And so it was just a happy accident.
Pete Mockaitis
Well, yeah, if it wasn’t AI, it’d be something, you know? Fill in the blank. Pandemic, revolutionary technology, geopolitical tumult, there’s always something. And so in your book, you mentioned that when we feel uncertain, we tend to do a couple suboptimal things. Can you lay those out for us?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
I think the big thing is that it impacts our decision-making where it really causes us to skew to the negative side. And so when there’s uncertainty, we’re more worried about threats. Like, it’s almost evolutionary, right? Like, we’re here because our ancestors paid attention to the sound in the bushes and survived.
And so the problem with that, with uncertainty, is that that means that if it’s skewing us to only consider the negative, then we’re missing the opportunities. And anytime there’s change, there’s opportunities.
Anybody who can figure out how to leverage change or solve a problem, and change creates lots of problems, both of those are opportunities. And so the brain automatically shuts down into focusing on the negative and, in doing that, we also become more risk-averse.
So we try to protect what we have instead of taking, so everything’s going in the wrong direction. You almost have to force yourself to open up. And a lot of that is trying to force yourself into curiosity.
It seems to be the best way in order to open back up your brain is to start asking questions just to satisfy curiosity. Start running experiments that allow you enough risk to be able to get more information.
Like, if you look at it instead of, “I’m taking a risk,” you look at it instead of, “I’m going to learn something,” and set up the experiments to be able to do that, then you’re sort of biting away at the uncertainty, while also effectively coping with it.
Because there are also people who go to the other extreme with uncertainty where they’re like, some people will shut down, like they literally just shut down. The brain shuts down, their actions shut down, they kind of freeze.
And then there will be people who hate uncertainty so much that they’ll try to take control. And like you said before, they’ll be like, “This is going to happen,” and then take actions about it when they actually don’t have enough information.
And so the smaller moves with the focus on experimentation and learning seem to be the best way to sort of like chisel away at uncertainty.
Pete Mockaitis
I love that idea of the smaller moves that focus on experimentation and learning are so key. One of my favorite stories in this zone is I’m thinking about Tony Hsieh when he started Zappos.
Now we’re all very comfortable buying shoes online. But if we go back in time, there was a time where it was genuinely unknown, “Is anybody going to want to buy a shoe online? I mean, you got to try them on, for goodness sake. How could you buy a pair of shoes without knowing how they feel, what it’s like when you walk around in them? Is it tight in weird places that you don’t want it tight, or too loose,” all the things, the support on your arch, you know? Like, how could you possibly determine that?
So what he did was he moseyed over to a shoe store and said, “Can I take pictures of your shoes? And if I sell them online, I’ll pay you for the shoes and then I’ll ship them to folks.” And they said, “Okay. Nothing lost on our side,” says the shoe store owner.
And from a strictly, like profit-and-loss perspective, this is a terrible business move because you’re not making any profit if you’re buying the shoes at retail price and then selling them at the same retail price and doing the work and the shipping. It’s, like, a terrible financial operation, but a pristinely beautiful learning operation.
And, sure enough, he was able to see, “By golly, when you make the return process easy and free and guaranteed, folks are totally cool with buying shoes online. Well, I guess we’re off to the races.”
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Right. And you see that with so many things. I mean, like, we’re both wearing eyeglasses. Like Zenni is a great opportunity to buy a cheap pair of eyeglasses.
This is, again, something you’re used to trying on. And so what did they do? They gave you, like, a face thing that you put in there and then you could try on the different shapes, and so you kind of get a sense. And then you could send them back if they didn’t work. All of that is to reduce uncertainty, to reduce the barriers that uncertainty puts up with adoption.
Pete Mockaitis
Okay, so that’s a good move in terms of thinking about doing these experiments. Could you share with us some additional stories and perspectives for folks who were feeling the uncertainty, they were at risk for making some foolish decisions, and then, ultimately, what tactics and strategies they used to prevail under those conditions?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
So the one that comes to immediate mind is somebody we’ve coached who really wasn’t happy in their job but, at the same time, they were reluctant to retire. It wasn’t necessarily like the organization itself. It’s, like, they were, I think I would say, fundamentally, bored with what they were doing and they’d been doing it for a while.
So it wasn’t an organizational issue. It was more like a lot of people at about seven years. Actually, it’s like the seven-year itch of, like, work. And so they were at that point where they’re like, “Well, if I retire, I can then do this nonprofit that I can work in, I can volunteer in this nonprofit, and it’ll really fulfill me.”
But they were afraid to make the step because that’s a big deal, like retiring and not having money and going into a nonprofit. And I think we started out with the initial conversation was, “What if instead you work for them, and then they’re like, ‘Well, you know.’” There were things that why they wanted to stay, like better healthcare. There were issues that were keeping them in the organization.
Then I’m like, “All right, what if you, basically, do sort of a side hustle with this nonprofit where, like, you get used to them, you get to see whether or not what you’re offering is valuable to them, you get a sense for, like, being in that space while still maintaining this job? And so you’re running an experiment and then you can switch over.” And that worked very well.
And so they, basically, like, worked on the side hustle for about a year in this nonprofit, and they did, in fact, love it. And the nonprofit made enough room for them.
I think, initially, the nonprofit couldn’t really give them, like, a full time job. And, certainly, they were not replacing everything that this person was earning in the organization. And that was also part of the calculation is, like, “How much do you need in order to be able to do this?”
And so they were able to slide into that, see the reality, what it would be like, and then eventually they moved on over. But they weren’t going to do it before that. They were going to wait until they hit, you know, 70, which was a number of years away, and get the full retirement and then do this thing that they wanted. And that’s a lot of years of being bored.
Pete Mockaitis
Yeah, it sure is. Well, that’s a great story and, yes, I’m all for it. You know, your subtitle is “14 Strategies for Work Success in a Chaotic World.” Cindi, if I could put you on the spot, could I have you give us the lightning fast overview of the strategy, one or two sentences for what that is, and then we’ll dig into where it seems the juiciest?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Okay.
Pete Mockaitis
So, first, “Get a hold of yourself.”
Dr. Cindi Baldi
It’s basically just getting a hold of your emotions. That’s what we’re really talking about. And because uncertainty, again, does spike a lot of negative emotions, and so we have some practical tools in that chapter that help you basically step back.
My favorite in the chapter is the 10-10-10 rule, where you’re in a situation and maybe, like, you’re on the cusp of overreacting or possibly doing some damage to a relationship. And the rule is, “Ask yourself if in 10 hours, 10 days, or 10 weeks this is even going to matter.”
And you sort of like talk yourself through what that looks like, how you feel about this particular situation. And you could do different increments, but it’s basically pulling out in time, “Is this even going to matter?” And when you do that, a lot of things go away.
Pete Mockaitis
Okay. Thank you. And strategy two, “Convert experience into wisdom.”
Dr. Cindi Baldi
So this chapter, “Convert experience to wisdom,” is just the fundamental flaw that we’re all very busy. And in being busy, we don’t do a whole lot of reflecting. And if we’re not doing any reflecting, we’re not doing any learning.
And if we’re not doing the reflecting when it comes to uncertainty, we’re not actually getting better at assessing our ability to predict and take risks. And so you have to set aside time in order to do your after-action review and see what you could have done better, what you did well, how you might change going forward.
I mean, we do this, like, personally all the time in our business. Like, every single time we put a proposal together and go out, and whether we get it and then more information comes in, or we don’t get it, we’re like, “Okay, what could we have done different? Did we do the right thing?”
Because sometimes no deal is a deal, “Did we do the right thing? How could we improve our odds next time? What would we pursue differently?” So, like, any time that you’re going through something, especially with uncertainty, because you don’t even know what you don’t know with uncertainty, but, like, “How might I have actually been able to tackle this a little bit smarter?”
Pete Mockaitis
I like that a lot. It’s necessary to learn or you’re just going to keep doing the same thing. And we’ve had guests talk about having a decision journal or whatnot, or just a regular process, especially if you have a recurring thing that’s happening.
We had a pastor, who said every Monday, they discuss what went down on the Sunday and how could they make it better and better and better. And so you just got 52 shots at improvement every year that you can go to a really cool place.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
That you’re actually getting. Because you could also get up and talk 52 times in a year and do no reflection, and you’re definitely not going to get any better. We have somebody who works for us, and she works for us because when we first started out, she was in the room and we asked her to take notes and she gave us, like, each, like 10 pages of notes.
Like, she’s paying attention to the audience and what they were reacting to and our weird micro expressions and, you know, like buggy eyes or like weird little gestures that you do. Like, every speaker has like those little things that they do.
And, like, she had it all down, and it was fantastic. Like, we periodically have her go to gigs just to do that because she’s so observant and so good at giving feedback. But, otherwise, you just continue on with the quirk.
Pete Mockaitis
Yeah, certainly. And even if you’re doing it but it’s only your own perspective, you’re not seeing some stuff. So I like that a lot. And, third, “Place your bets.”
Dr. Cindi Baldi
So, I mean, this is, again, about like risk assessment, of course, and just the fact that, like, when we have something to lose, we become risk-averse. It’s Kahneman’s work, Kahneman and Tversky’s work.
And so there’s danger in that. Like, what we see in organizations is people who have something, like they may have made a certain level and it’s kind of, it’s a life that fits the image, enough of the image of what they thought they would get, right? So they feel like they have something.
And so they don’t take the risk to maybe pursue a promotion, or a different track of learning, or even just a higher position, whether in that organization or a different organization, because they’re afraid of rocking the boat and missing what they have.
And so we see a number of people on the “I have something and I’m risk-averse,” side inside organizations. Like, “I know I’m not really happy but I have this and it gives me a comfortable life, it gives me the life that fits my expectations, and I want to be able to hold on to that.”
“Because what if I go to a different organization and it looks better from the outside, but I get in there and I’m miserable, I’m more miserable than I am right now?” And so they stay. They stay in misery instead of taking that chance.
Pete Mockaitis
That’s good. Thank you. If you could highlight for me, what are a couple strategies here that are just transformationally fantastic for people that we just have to talk about?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
So I like “explore and exploit” a great deal, and there’s this just art in building something which would be like explore, and then not getting so enamored on the explore that we forget to, like, exploit it.
And I know exploit has a negative connotation, but in this case, I mean, I’ve worked with somebody who did photo booths, like the live video booths that we now see everywhere. And they were constantly buying new equipment, and that’s very expensive.
And so they’re always experimenting, trying to like up the game with the equipment, instead of buying a set, like having a good set, and then spending the time to figure out how to leverage that and, basically, get your money back on it.
And so that’s the exploit phase. Like, the explore phase is, “Hey, this is really cool technology. And what should I use? And I’m going to buy something.” And then the exploit is, “Okay, I have this and I’m going to go for a while, understanding that, like, even as I breathe, this thing is like getting outdated,” because that’s what technology is.
And so you’re trying to do both of those things where, like, you get enough of bang for your buck on the exploit side to be able to fund the explore side. And with uncertainty, a lot of the time, you either get people who, like, really fall for the curiosity and the learning, and they don’t come out of the explore, or you get the people who get so accustomed.
And this, I think, is the more common. You get people who are so used to the existing system that they have that they don’t upgrade when they should. So I’ll give you a practical example from, actually, my own family.
So my parents, they own a drive-in movie theater. And we just had a celebration for somebody who was important in our community who passed away. And so we hosted free movies for everybody.
And so I’m sitting out there, I’m walking around the cars, I’m talking to everybody, and I’m sitting there, and we have these digital projectors that we’ve had since we were forced to go digital projectors, which was a huge investment.
And I’m watching a movie, and I’m like, “Our movie is crap. Like, it’s not good enough.” And so, like, it was a huge investment. You had to take it out a long time. We probably have had them double the lifespan. And so we did the exploit part.
And so now I’m back into, “Okay, what are my options to up the game here so that way we have a good picture?” And that throws off all sorts of uncertainty because that, again, changes the financial dynamics of a business that doesn’t have a whole lot of roof on it.
Pete Mockaitis
It’s a drive-in. It’s, literally, roofless.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Well, exactly. Except for the snack bar and the projection booth. But so, like, it’s that kind of pull-and-play that you’re dealing with. I also see it with just this country. Like, we just came back from China, and this country is still in the phase of exploiting our existing transportation systems, our existing technology.
I mean, you go to China, Japan, South Korea, or Singapore, and there’s no wait at their equivalent TSA. There’s, like, one dude working there, you walk up, it scans your face, you walk through. And it works perfectly.
Then you look at the US, like, obviously, we have the technology, but we’re still stuck in the old way. And we have to switch from exploit into explore. So there’s that one.
Pete Mockaitis
Cindi, I like this so much. It is a balancing act and it is an art because, I think, it’s a bit of a reality check for me personally. Like, I really like exploring. It’s fun. It’s new. It’s innovative. It’s intriguing. And I could get down the rabbit hole of, well, now, for example, there’s all these speech-to-text tools that are so much better than they used to be for productivity.
Like, back in the day, Dragon NaturallySpeaking, no offense, was terrible and I hated it. And so now there’s all these things, like Whispr Flow and Aqua Voice, and like a dozen other pieces like it. And it’s, like, I could spend all day playing with them, testing their accuracy.
And it’s not really worth it, right, because it’s like, “They’re all pretty good now. You could probably just grab one in 20 minutes of research and call it good.” And yet, I just really enjoy the exploring. It’s fun, interesting, and intriguing.
But in order to really be effective, we’ll need to do a good bit of exploiting. And then come one, two, three years from now, it’s probably well worth it to take a look back into the explore phase and say, “Hey, this app has been delightful for me, but, you know, are they still the top of the heap or should I be looking around for at for something else right now that can do it even better or at a lower price?”
But then, again, you could do that, I’m thinking of AI, in particular. Like, everyday, I think it’s literally everyday, there is a new development of some kind.
And you could spend your whole working life exploring all the cool, fun, new, interesting things in the universe of AI, and maybe that’s great if you run an AI YouTube channel and you’re sharing that and that’s great.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
I think that’s how some people have handled it.
Pete Mockaitis
Yeah, but for most of us, no, you just kind of got to know, “Oh, that thing will be useful for me. I’m going to go ahead and bring that into my life, my workflows, and then just, like, peek my head up from time to time to get a sense of, “Is there anything game-changingly new that I should be using? All these YouTube thumbnails seem to be suggesting it is, but actually is it?”
And so, yeah, boy, you can really marinate in that one. Like, “What is the correct balance of explore/exploit given the life cycle and what I’m trying to achieve, and the landscape around me and how it’s evolved?”
Dr. Cindi Baldi
And I want to tie that back to what I had initially said with, like, dealing with the negativity when uncertainty sets in and sort of being like frozen. The remedy to that is the curiosity. And so the remedy is explore. And once you get into it, you love it. You might have uncertainty about going to, say, like a foreign country or even just a city that you haven’t been to.
Like when I say I’m going to New York City, like there are people who are petrified of that. But you go, and like it’s amazing. It’s an amazing city. There’s a ton of stuff that’s really cool to do there. And you start getting all these ideas of bringing home like, “How can I use this in my daily life? Or how can I use this in work?”
And it’s that level of explore that then kicks off all these other ideas, and so it’s very enticing. Once you get yourself into it, you have to make sure that you don’t just perpetually stay in it. You have to do something with it.
Pete Mockaitis
Yeah, that’s great. Okay. Well, now can you share with us the notion of “Striking the right balance”?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
So “Striking the right balance,” I believe, without looking inside the chapter, I believe that that’s the one that I would call getting a hold of, like, your brain, like mental management, basically, because, again, curiosity causes us to flip to the negative side. And so it kicks off things like negative rumination, right?
And we want to practice possible scenarios, but we don’t want to be stuck, like, constantly going over the possible negative scenario over and over again. We want to also practice positive scenarios, right? Practice is a good thing.
I grew up, again, in a drive-in movie theater at a very young age. I won’t tell you how young, because my parents weren’t paying attention. I was the fourth one. So I like to say that they ran out of energy. So, like, I was watching horror movies very young.
And, like, a lot of people would be horrified at that – horror movie, horrified. But in life, I’ll say that having watched horror movies actually has a good application because I’ve thought through some, like, dire situations, right?
Pete Mockaitis
Oh, you’re ready. When the slasher comes your way, you know what to do.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Yeah, I am. There was somebody who, like, was in my house one time.
Pete Mockaitis
Oh, dear.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Yeah, I know. It was very scary. It was the middle of the night. The dog woke me up. And the first thing I said was, “I know not to go down and investigate and ask them what they’re doing in here.”
But, you know, like you’ve thought it through because of the experience of watching, or that you’ve intentionally practiced, whether it’s a conversation, like a high-stakes conversation, or a high-stakes situation that you’re walking into, that you’ve practiced both the downside and the upside.
And it’s true, you may get neither, but it’s in the practicing that it builds, A, your confidence. But, B, like, it’s sometimes surprising, the little nuggets that you practice in advance that are helpful.
So the practice is good. The downside is, if you keep spinning that situation, whether it’s a possible future situation or a past situation that actually did happen, and you’re spinning it in your brain over and over again and ruminating.
And so this part of the chapter is like, “How do you do the mental management to basically make sure that when uncertainty kicks off rumination on you, which it has a tendency to do, how do you get out of that?”
Pete Mockaitis
Okay. Well, Cindi, two things. First, we have to know what happened with the dude in your house?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Oh, sure. So this is when I was really young. I was in college. So I, first, closed my door and locked it, and then walked over to the window to see if maybe, perhaps, it was my roommate coming home in the middle of the night, and then my knees went out from underneath me because her car wasn’t there and I knew it wasn’t her.
And so then, because this is the days of landlines, I, fortunately, had a yellow lab who had eaten the answering machine that sat downstairs with the phone. So who was in my house had to go up past my room to get to the landline extension. And they must have figured out that like I was talking.
So I had time to basically pick up the phone and call the police. And then while I’m on the phone with the police, they picked up. I heard them click.
Pete Mockaitis
Whoa!
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Yeah. And then they jumped out the balcony.
Pete Mockaitis
Okay.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Yeah, so they knew the police were coming and they got the hell out of there. But I was very lucky.
Pete Mockaitis
Did they take anything?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
No, no, they didn’t take anything.
Pete Mockaitis
Okay. Well, I’m glad you’re safe and well.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
I owe that to the dog.
Pete Mockaitis
Thank you, dog. Okay. So we just had to close that loop.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
I understand.
Pete Mockaitis
Secondly, when it comes to rumination, how do you stop it?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
I mean, obviously meditation, but I would rather put like a pencil through my eyeball than meditate. It’s just, like, not really for me. I do recognize that it really is very helpful and people who can do it and enjoy it, I grant you all the power in the world.
The ways that I do it, I do it in two different ways that I find effective for people. The first is doing a level of exercise that is a little bit stressful, but mostly comfortable.
It’s, like, not at the point where you’re struggling, but, like, your brain can basically stop thinking. You’re like almost on an autopilot, but it’s occupied enough with, like, the strain where it doesn’t have excess resources to go bouncing around thinking about other things.
And I find that to be almost a form of meditation, so I can do that swimming or walking. And then the other one I find to be very helpful is diving into somebody else’s world. So fiction, picking up a fiction book and basically diving into somebody else’s world causes your world inside your head to shut off.
Pete Mockaitis
Yes. And I think there’s science suggesting it’s best to do that with paper, if you can, as opposed to another screen.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
I don’t know. I don’t think I’ve seen that. Definitely for writing. I’ll have to look up the reading one, though. That’s interesting. I know that there’s research on reading that basically it really ramps up your empathy.
Pete Mockaitis
Yeah. But, as far as you’re concerned, personally, it’s like you’re down reading fiction any way you find it.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Yeah. And other people, like it’s basically, like we run that exercise in groups, it’s anything that just gets you almost into flow. So anything that you really enjoy, because flow is basically you lose track of time and you’re just in the moment. And so your brain is just in the moment. It’s not thinking about a possible future or a past that you didn’t like.
And when you quiet down the brain, even for periods of time, when you come back out of it, you’re just more in control over it. I mean, I think that’s why people really do like meditation as it gives them a level of control over their brain, that without practicing it they didn’t have.
Pete Mockaitis
Well, Cindi, I like these notions a lot. And I’m thinking, I think it was Kwame Christian, a guest of the show, who talked about forced mindfulness. He was talking about in the context of jujitsu. He’s like, “You know what? When there’s a large man choking you, you can’t help but be very present to what’s happening in front of you.” I was like, “Yeah, that makes sense. That makes a lot of sense.”
And I think about that for cold plunges, in terms of, like, my mind could be going in all kinds of directions, and then I get in some cold water and all my mind is going is, “Whoo!” you know? Like, all other thoughts have ceased and I like it a lot.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Yeah, I like that. I like the cold plunge example. That’s good. I like actually the being strangled one, in jujitsu one. Like, specifically, jujitsu.
Pete Mockaitis
Yeah. Okay, so you can meditate, you can read fiction, you can do jujitsu, cold plunge.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
There’s a lot of ways. It’s what works for you.
Pete Mockaitis
There’s a lot of ways that you shut down rumination hard and have no choice but to engage with the present.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
And so, like, that’s the thing. There’s probably endless numbers of ways that individuals do it. It’s just paying attention to what works for you.
Pete Mockaitis
Yeah. Beautiful. Well, Cindi, tell me, anything else you want to make sure to mention before we hear about some of your favorite things?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
I think the only other thing that I would like to mention is sort of circling back to one of our original conversations about uncertainty driving group affiliation, is think about the groups that are really important to you and if there’s uncertainty there, what is it that you are trying to avoid? Like, is there a better way to manage that uncertainty? Because I just think it’s wonderful to be part of groups for a social component.
But you always have to counterbalance that with how much power do they have over you and your thinking, and even, like, the data that you process, like the information that you process? It has a huge impact over people.
And so we should, intentionally, periodically, look around at the groups that we belong to, and think, “Why this group? What uncertainty is it solving? Is there another way for me to solve that uncertainty or get comfortable with the uncertainty? And am I okay with how much power that this group has over me?”
Pete Mockaitis
Beautiful. Thank you.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
You’re welcome.
Pete Mockaitis
Well, now could you share a favorite quote, something you find inspiring?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
You know, I have, like, a partial quote. I think it was from Pope. And it was, “Drink deep or taste not the Pierian Spring.” And I know that there was more context to it, but, basically, what it’s saying is like, you know, we’re never going to know everything. Drink what you can, drink deeply, but then you have to take action.
Pete Mockaitis
All right. And a favorite book?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Kent Nerburn, Simple Truths.
Pete Mockaitis
And is there a key nugget you share that seems to really connect and resonate with folks, they quote it back to you often?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
You know, I was talking to my counterpart, who’s, he’s behind the scenes, Jack. And the tripwire seems to actually, we talk about tripwires in the book. And, basically, like a tripwire is an if-then statement, like, “If this happens, then I will do this.” But it’s, like, the pre-planning of when you will take action.
So, for example, if you’re going to delegate something, and you’re worried about the delegation, like, the tripwire is, “How much room am I going to give for this person to, like, experiment and sort of like adapt to the delegation? And what do they need to do in order to trip a wire where I’m going to jump in?” That would be like an example.
So it gives people a little bit of space to be able to, like, learn and screw up, and you’re not, like, overreacting to everything.
Pete Mockaitis
Beautiful. And if folks want to learn more or get in touch, where would you point them?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Well, I mean, I have my own podcast, which you were on. Thank you very much for doing that. We’re Management Muse. And then I’m also available on Culsure.com, which, yeah, I got to spell the culsure because it’s very close to another word. So it’s C-U-L-S-U-R-E.com, and all the contact information is there.
Pete Mockaitis
And do you have a final challenge or call to action for folks looking to be awesome at their jobs?
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Well, I think my final call to action is, step one, think bigger right now, because you probably have just settled down into, like, a routine and life is busy and you’re not really shaking it up. And also uncertainty may be, like, holding you down a little bit. So think bigger about the possibilities for you, and then start asking.
Because what we tend to find is people, think if they work hard that they’ll get recognized and the organization will promote them fairly. But the problem is that an organization is smaller at the top than the bottom. And so if you want any shot at movement, you have to go in and ask.
And, yeah, it’s true, you may not get it right away, you may not get it at all, but if the people above you know that you’re interested in it, they’re probably going to do some things to help you get there even if, ultimately, you don’t get there through them.
So that’s my advice, is that make sure you get out there and ask.
Pete Mockaitis
And you have a story of someone who doubled their salary via asking, and it wasn’t even that hard. Tell us that story.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Yeah, so I do have that story. And so I will say that it’s been surprising just how much ground we can get by asking. And so this one particular woman, her job had expanded to be multiple positions. So people in the organization quit and she was extremely capable, and so they kept on adding a workload onto her.
And then that thing was really happening and, like, they weren’t offering up a salary because, largely, the CEO, which I don’t really agree with this, but CEO was like, “Hey, it’s market rate. If she’s willing to take it then it’s fair.” That was that was his perception.
Pete Mockaitis
I don’t know. Fair is not the word. If she’s willing to take it, then you’re getting away with it. I wouldn’t call it fair.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Right. I agree with you. I don’t agree with that. And, in fact, in fairness to the number two of that organization, he literally was, like, “Help her figure out how to ask.”
And so, you know, I was getting her mentally ready for the asking, and it was frightening for her. But, again, she had, like, three jobs that she was holding down in this one organization.
And so then we started like, basically trying to get the added value by, basically, doing these three things together, we did our best to try to piece together evidence to support what we were going to ask for, figure out what we were going to ask for, and then ask for it.
And then we practiced it and practiced it and she went in and she was very nervous, but she asked for double her salary and he said, “Done,” like didn’t even argue. So in that CEO’s defense, it really was about, like, what you’re willing to accept.
Like, he knew he was getting a deal. He wasn’t going to offer up the raise unless she felt like she wasn’t getting a deal.
Pete Mockaitis
Okay. Ask.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
Ask and do your homework, but prepare to ask.
Pete Mockaitis
All right. Cindi, thank you.
Dr. Cindi Baldi
You’re welcome.






